Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Properties for Sale in Key West, FL

Researching this community? View previous sales at Key West Realty Cos Sub. Let one our Keys area experts help you out.

Total Listings 17
    Key West
    $299,900 667 (SqFt)
    • 2
    • 1
    • Condo

    2521 Fogarty Avenue 2
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 0
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    DRASTICALLY REDUCED!!! One of the best deals in town. Great property in Mid-town. Renovated condo on a quiet street with a super location. Use as a fabulous rental or make it your home. Easy access to N. Roosevelt and Flagler. Ample off-street parking. There is a private pool for your leisurely enjoyment. A new stove, new washer/dryer, new flooring in bedroom, & tavertine floors and counter tops. One of five total units in a private, desirable area, just minutes from shopping and beaches. Priced to sell, wont last. A MUST SEE!!!
      Details
    Key West
    $374,500 1,491 (SqFt)
    • 3
    • 2
    • Single Family

    2402 Fogarty Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 3
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Spacious. light and airy are just a few of the words to describe this Midtown single family home. True comfort and space will be yours with this family oriented 3BR / 2 1/2BA home conveniently located close to shopping, and just a short bike ride to Old Town.
      Details
    Key West
    $400,000 1,250 (SqFt)
    • 2
    • 1
    • Single Family

    1301 1St Street
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 3
    Side of Island: Bay/Gulf
    Dockage: None

    Short Sale. Bad roof, lots of water damage and mold.
      Details
    Key West
    $405,000 677 (SqFt)
    • 2
    • 1
    • Condo

    2521 Fogarty Avenue 3
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 0
    Side of Island: Ocean
    Dockage: None

    Gorgeous & affordable Key West living. Close to everything. This 2/1 is in a completely renovated condo conversion. Travertine floors, countertops & a pool are just a few of the amenities. close midtown location and off street parking a plus. Hurry this wont last.
      Details
    Key West
    $425,000 2,214 (SqFt)
    • 5
    • 2
    • Single Family

    2609 Staples Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 3
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Spacious concrete block 2,214 Sq Ft. home.5BD/2BTH.50X100 lot partially fenced.Room for pool in back yard, room for a couple of vehicles in yard. Interesting floor plan that would work perfect if you have in laws or grown children living with you.Possibility for two living room/ family room areas. Tile floors throughout home.Needs to be upgraded (windows & baths).Separate laundry utility room
      Details
    Key West
    $499,000 1,670 (SqFt)
    • 5
    • 3
    • Single Family

    2509 Harris Street
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Property has 2 homes with their own separate entrances. Rent both, live and one and rent the other or turn the back home into your guest house. Main house has 3 bedrooms and 2 bath with double high ceilings over the kitchen and dining room and wood spiral staircase up to a sleeping/storage loft. The home was decorated by a tile artist may years ago and has a beautiful mosaic tile floor in the dining room and other built in art all around. Outside there is an outdoor shower, storage,old fashioned bottle wall, yard and an elevated building that can be used as an storage, workshop or artists studio. The back house has 2 bedrooms / 1 bath with a lovely screened front porch. Call for a showing today!
      Details
    Key West
    $499,000 1,670 (SqFt)
    • 5
    • 3
    • Duplex

    2509 Harris Street
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Property has 2 homes with their own separate entrances. Rent both, live and one and rent the other or turn the back home into your guest house. Main house has 3 bedrooms and 2 bath with double high ceilings over the kitchen and dining room and wood spiral staircase up to a sleeping/storage loft. The home was decorated by a tile artist may years ago and has a beautiful mosaic tile floor in the dining room and other built in art all around. Outside there is an outdoor shower, storage, old fashioned bottle wall, yard and an elevated building that can be used as an storage, workshop or artists studio. The back house has 2 bedrooms / 1 bath with a lovely screened front porch. Call for a showing today
      Details
    Key West
    $499,000 1,835 (SqFt)
    • 3
    • 2
    • Duplex

    2002 Seidenberg Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Legal duplex you can rent now or seller has plans and survey available soon to build two detached single family homes. Permits will be ready soon. This is a rare opportunity in Key West so dont miss out and purchase now! Tenant occupied so at least 24 hour notice to show.
      Details
    Key West
    $499,900 1,021 (SqFt)
    • 3
    • 1
    • Single Family

    2213 Harris Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Ocean
    Dockage: None

    Home sweet home! Updated home with metal roof, HVAC, impact glass windows(150mph), hurricane shutters, Atrium doors, recessed lights, custom plantation blinds throughout, two 200 amp CB panels, kitchen cabinets & appliances. AND step into the fabulous backyard with 1200 sq ft pool deck surrounding the new heated, salt tablet filtered pool & hot tub with waterfall! All surrounded by 6 ft privacy wall!The home is filled with light and is open with a nice flow for entertaining family & friends. Three full bedrooms,each with plentiful closet space, one bath and architectural plans in place for 2nd bath, laundry room for full size washer & dryer. This sweet home has it all!
      Details
    Key West
    $569,000 1,092 (SqFt)
    • 2
    • 2
    • Single Family

    1831 Harris Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 3
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    A recently updated, perfectly peaceful piece of paradise in mid-town! A large corner lot with 2BR/2BA, a heated pool, a 20KW home generator that was installed in 2011, off-street parking, a mother-in law cottage, granite counter tops and stainless steel appliances in the main residence. The existing roof was replaced in 2009 and the 2.5 ton central A/C was installed in 2007. A privacy fence and lush landscaping surrounds the property for a sense of seclusion.
      Details
    Key West
    $639,000 2,406 (SqFt)
    • 3
    • 3
    • Single Family

    2329 Fogarty Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Charming Mid Town Key West residence. This updated 3BR/3BA home with over 2,400 Sq. Ft. of living space features impactglass windows, stainless steel appliances, a balcony overlooking the pool, 2 master suites, a home office that could easily be converted into a 4th bedroom & a built in outdoor bar/sitting area. In 2009 the pool was re-plastered and new equipment was also installed along with new 4 ton & 2 ton A/C systems.
      Details
    Key West
    $695,000 2,755 (SqFt)
    • 4
    • 3
    • Single Family

    2107 Flagler Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 3
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    London Contemporary meets Key West chic in this stunningly renovated 4BD/3BA property. Modern kitchen has granite countertops and stainless appliances, and the open floor plan flows from the spacious indoor living area to the large, private back yard. Perfect for entertaining, theres a waterfall swimming pool, outdoor shower, gazebo, and built-in grill. Huge master suite with home office occupies the entire second story, and a treetop deck and stairs offer views and access to the back yard. Additional bedrooms and bathrooms are located on the ground level. Hurricane impact windows and doors throughout provide security, insurance discounts and sound proofing. Off-street parking and fully fenced for privacy, this is a Midtown Tropical Oasis!
      Details
    Key West
    $699,000 1,530 (SqFt)
    • 4
    • 3
    • Single Family

    2624 Seidenberg Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Ocean
    Dockage: None

    Spacious home on a 10,000 sq ft lot. Wide open living area, good sized side yards and a 50ft X 10ft pool to enjoy in rear. Deck offers great entertaining area and surroundings, privacy, mature vegetation. Brand new paint job on house and decking. There is a lot more to this home. You have to take a look to appreciate all the amenities. It is a feel good home with a lot of yard to play with. Centrally located in the Island City of Key West! Seller is a FL Licensed real estate agent.
      Details
    Key West
    $899,000 1,922 (SqFt)
    • 4
    • 3
    • Duplex

    2310 Staples Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Fantastic opportunity to purchase two homes on a double lot in the heart of Key West. This meticulously maintained home sits on a corner lot surrounded by mature Mahogany and Gumbo Limbo trees, orchids and a butterfly garden. With a nice floor plan, the main house features 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, plus a private guest cottage on the adjacent lot to accommodate your family and friends. French doors lead from the living area to the botanical gardens and to the large pool area with a shaded deck, perfect for outdoor wining and dining. The spacious kitchen features wooden cabinets and stainless steel appliances and opens to the family room with cathedral ceilings and skylights. The master suite has its separate entrance, vaulted ceilings and a large master bath. There is plenty of green space
      Details
    Key West
    $899,000 2,659 (SqFt)
    • 6
    • 3
    • Single Family

    2605 Patterson Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: Yes MM: 2
    Side of Island: Ocean
    Dockage: None

    TWO and ONE HALF LOTS!!! This midtown home is custom built with love. A family/play/vacation home with an updated kitchen, gracious living room, lanai, six bedrooms, three full baths and plenty of space to live and play. The interior of this home is over 2650sf and the lot is large enough to add on! A two car garage, car port, storage, workshop and natural seawall on a canal with water access are just a few of the amenities you will find in this spacious home which is the first time ever on the market for sale.
      Details
    Key West
    $899,000 1,922 (SqFt)
    • 4
    • 3
    • Single Family

    2310 Staples Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 2
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Fantastic opportunity to purchase two homes on a double lot in the heart of Key West. This meticulously maintained home sits on a corner lot surrounded by mature Mahogany and Gumbo Limbo trees, orchids and a butterfly garden. With a nice floor plan, the main house features 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, plus a private guest cottage on the adjacent lot to accommodate your family and friends. French doors lead from the living area to the botanical gardens and to the large pool area with a shaded deck, perfect for outdoor wining and dining. The spacious kitchen features wooden cabinets and stainless steel appliances and opens to the family room with cathedral ceilings and skylights. The master suite has its separate entrance, vaulted ceilings and a large master bath. There is plenty of green space
      Details
    Key West
    $1,345,000 3,840 (SqFt)
    • 8
    • 4

    2618 Fogarty Avenue
    KEY WEST, FL 33040

    Key West Realty Cos Subdivision Waterfront: No MM: 1
    Side of Island: Median
    Dockage: None

    Rare find in Key West. 4- 2/1 legal units. Very well maintained. Great rental income or housing for businesses in need. Rents are currently lower than market rate. Separate meters for each unit. A must see!
      Details
    Most Recent Sales - (58) - Key West Realty Cos Sub as of 2015-08-28
    Sale Date Address Sale Price $/SF List Price Sq. Ft. Type Bd/Ba Days Listed
    08-20-2015 2005 Fogarty $395,000 $474 $399,000 832 Single Family 2/1 70
    08-18-2015 1311 7th $325,000 $348 $349,000 933 Single Family 2/1 107
    08-06-2015 2024 Fogarty $416,000 $270 $429,000 1,540 Single Family 3/2 86
    07-08-2015 2405 Flagler $460,100 $311 $364,000 1,479 Duplex 4/2 57
    07-07-2015 2211 Flagler $420,000 $381 $449,000 1,101 Single Family 3/2 336
    07-02-2015 2012 Patterson $375,000 $312 $425,000 1,200 Single Family 3/2 70
    07-01-2015 2433 Harris $350,000 $420 $374,000 832 Single Family 2/1 143
    06-22-2015 2112 Harris $370,000 $305 $379,000 1,212 Single Family 2/1 134
    06-22-2015 2209 Flagler $426,000 $273 $339,900 1,560 Duplex 4/2 56
    06-01-2015 2007 Seidenberg $672,000 $320 $699,000 2,096 Single Family 4/3 416
    05-14-2015 2519 Seidenberg $435,000 $442 $425,000 984 Single Family 2/1 50
    05-06-2015 2400 Patterson $390,000 $260 $399,000 1,500 Single Family 4/2 94
    04-20-2015 2113 Harris $379,000 $445 $379,000 850 Single Family 2/1 70
    04-17-2015 2305 Seidenberg $250,000 $132 $289,000 1,890 Single Family 3/3 141
    04-15-2015 1026 Von Phister $1,800,000 $806 $1,995,000 2,233 Single Family 4/4 73
    03-30-2015 1902 Seidenberg $516,500 $452 $525,000 1,142 Single Family 5/2 447
    03-27-2015 2425 Patterson $335,475 $232 $339,800 1,440 Single Family 4/2 95
    02-12-2015 2502 Harris $399,900 $444 $399,900 900 Single Family 3/2 87
    01-31-2015 2011 Staples $390,000 $217 $399,000 1,795 Single Family 4/2 268
    01-26-2015 2002 Seidenberg $350,000 $190 $350,000 1,835 Duplex 2/2 351
    01-02-2015 2434 Fogarty $400,000 $378 $439,000 1,057 Single Family 3/1 73
    12-17-2014 1319 2nd $312,900 $175 $262,800 1,781 Duplex 4/3 134
    11-21-2014 2212 Staples $614,250 $417 $713,000 1,470 Single Family 3/2 92
    11-21-2014 1414 5th $620,000 $268 $650,000 2,307 Single Family 5/4 85
    11-10-2014 2509 Fogarty $275,000 $280 $287,000 982 Single Family 2/2 36
    11-10-2014 1313 8th $305,550 $261 $202,700 1,168 Single Family 2/1 88
    11-03-2014 2008 Patterson $350,000 $406 $369,000 861 Single Family 3/1 225
    11-03-2014 2525 Patterson $447,000 $343 $449,900 1,300 Single Family 3/3 99
    10-31-2014 1311 7th $305,000 $328 $325,000 928 Single Family 2/1 208
    10-31-2014 2520 Seidenberg $327,000 $390 $349,000 838 Single Family 2/1 102
    10-30-2014 2627 Patterson $699,000 $1,127 $699,000 620 Single Family 2/2 1
    08-01-2014 2023 Staples $349,900 $318 $362,000 1,100 Single Family 2/2 219
    07-08-2014 2103 Fogarty $475,000 $288 $497,000 1,648 Single Family 3/2 120
    06-30-2014 1428 Whalton $835,000 $602 $869,000 1,386 Single Family 3/2 461
    06-06-2014 1405 2nd $484,000 $257 $518,000 1,880 Single Family 3/3 159
    06-03-2014 2625 Flagler $300,000 $367 $329,000 817 Single Family 2/1 212
    05-30-2014 2525 Flagler 2 $253,000 $366 $259,900 691 Condo 2/1 653
    05-23-2014 2615 Staples $360,000 $251 $367,200 1,430 Single Family 2/2 217
    05-16-2014 1525 Johnson $580,000 $376 $574,900 1,540 Single Family 3/3 71
    04-28-2014 2027 Staples $482,000 $318 $538,000 1,512 Duplex 4/2 95
    04-24-2014 2309 Flagler $475,000 $292 $499,000 1,624 Single Family 2/2 164
    04-23-2014 2335 Patterson $299,000 $235 $299,000 1,272 Half Duplex 2/2 58
    04-18-2014 2404 Patterson $376,000 $226 $379,000 1,657 Single Family 3/2 227
    04-11-2014 2514 Staples $425,000 $195 $529,000 2,174 Duplex 4/2 493
    04-09-2014 2427 Patterson $290,000 $424 $295,000 683 Single Family 1/1 72
    04-02-2014 2121 Fogarty $395,000 $157 $439,900 2,501 Duplex 4/4 158
    03-07-2014 2417 Patterson $355,500 $219 $333,000 1,619 Duplex 4/4 53
    02-28-2014 2430 Fogarty $380,000 $285 $449,000 1,330 Single Family 3/2 51
    02-13-2014 2618 Seidenberg $309,000 $463 $329,000 667 Single Family 1/1 73
    02-03-2014 2330 Seidenberg $672,500 $347 $689,000 1,938 Single Family 3/2 85
    01-24-2014 1019 Flagler $900,000 $276 $995,000 3,256 Misc Prop Rights / 54
    12-20-2013 1515 Johnson $665,000 $390 $664,000 1,704 Single Family 3/3 52
    12-13-2013 1906 Seidenberg $399,000 $235 $399,000 1,694 Duplex 6/2 99
    11-22-2013 1916 Staples $337,000 $382 $349,000 880 Single Family 2/1 72
    10-09-2013 2523 Flagler 3 $253,000 $366 $259,900 691 Condo 2/1 420
    10-03-2013 2527 Flagler 1 $253,000 $366 $259,900 691 Condo 2/1 414
    09-10-2013 2017 Harris $475,000 $344 $475,000 1,377 Single Family 2/2 300
    09-09-2013 2521 Fogarty UNIT 2 $220,000 $329 $225,000 667 Condo 2/1 276
    Thinking about selling your Key West Realty Cos Sub home?

    Get a free no obligation home value report and know your home's value, even if you are just curious. If you decide to sell or are considering it, our company specializes in selling homes in your community and we can provide you with the guidance on the process that will generate the most return on your investment. Inquire below for a free comparative market analysis of your property. All communication is private and no obligation.

    Provide us with some quick details so we can setup a free no obligation and confidential phone call.


      The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 08-28-2015.

      Shoreline Properties
      92300 Overseas Hwy Suite 303
      Tavernier, Florida 33070

      1(800) 692-3605
      Contact Us