Old Town ~ Unlisted Properties for Sale in Key West, FL

Researching this community? View previous sales at Old Town - Unlisted. Let one our Keys area experts help you out.

Total Listings 37
Order By:

416  Petronia Street 2 For Sale, MLS 584826
$384,900
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 389 SqFt Days Listed: 341
-9.44% ($40,100) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 36 Days Ago
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

One of the lowest priced listings in Old Town! Located in the heart of historic Key West and a half block away from Duval Street, this one bedroom, one bath condo is perfect for weekend getaways or an income-producing vacation rental. Steps away from popular spots such as Santiagos Bodega and Blue Heaven. A spacious bedroom, in-unit washer and dryer and low monthly maintenance fees make this condo a must-see. Located in an X-flood zone.

817  Eaton Street 5 For Sale, MLS 587110
$449,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 422 SqFt Days Listed: 181
-8.18% ($40,000) 4 Price Changes : Last Change 3 Days Ago
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: None

In the heart of Old Town Key West! Centrally located near top rated fine dining, shopping, and the Historic Seaport. This detached cottage is the perfect pied-a-terre just blocks to Duval & nestled off Gecko Lane. This two story detached unit offers light filled living space and private outdoor areas. Main level has full bath, wood floors, french doors. The upper level bedroom suite has laundry and powder room. Low maintenance fee of $202 per month! Furnished!

900  White Street 3 For Sale, MLS 588843
$499,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 955 SqFt Days Listed: 59
-5.85% ($31,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 12 Days Ago
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Second floor condo in the trees. Balcony overlooks White Street, great for people watching. 1889 Craftsman Bungalow home was converted into a 3 condo complex in 2007. This is a 2B/1Ba with 2 additional rooms suitable for storage, walk in closest or office. Spacious living room has a bank of windows affording lots of light and a breezy feeling. Kitchen has top of the line cabinets including a built in wine rack and a bread box. Pantry has pull out shelving with a 2nd and 3rd row storage. Stone counters, stainless appliances and wood floors throughout. Entrance to #3 is a gate on Olivia, before you reach White Street. New roof 2013. Tented 2015. X Flood Zone

1112  Margaret Street REAR For Sale, MLS 589882
$525,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 882 SqFt Days Listed: 4
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Idyllic Old Town location with habitable 2 bedroom, 1 bath, non-contributing building under mature canopy. Continue renting to wonderful locals, use now for rustic pied a terre, downtown small family home or build new, conforming structure. Many possibilities for this amazing property.New survey and elevation certificate just completed and HOA being finalized by Oropeza, Stones, Cardenas, so legal in tax roll has not yet been changed. Currently X flood zone.

1  Nassau Lane  For Sale, MLS 583135
$590,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 486 SqFt Days Listed: 443
-1.50% ($9,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 95 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Recently Renovated! Charmingly quaint and cozy 1BR/1BA Key West Cottage stands tasteful & modest on rare & quiet lane located just off of Fleming Street & conveniently close to the Historic Seaport & many more fun attractions & activities Key West has to offer such as restaurants, parks & local art galleries. More... The one story home includes a great sized kitchen with built-in cabinets, cathedral ceilings, laundry/utility room & hardwood/tile floors. Curtained by mature tropical foliage rests the perfect home for any young bachelor or retired couple seeking a tranquil island life setting.

3  Hutchinson Lane REAR For Sale, MLS 588483
$650,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 1,304 SqFt Days Listed: 82
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Tucked away at the end of Hutchinson Lane in Old Town-Key West, this well maintained two story concrete home offers impact windows, large rooms, and a small yard and patio perfect for al fresco dining and outdoor lounging. Conveniently located in the heart of Bahama Village with all of its old world Caribbean charm and within a couple of blocks of many historic landmarks, small neighborhood cafes, shopping, and Duval Street. Fully walled for privacy and surrounded by mature tropical foliage in a neighborhood reminiscent of Old Key West. Ready to move into or perfect for a rental opportunity. Very easy to show.

1112  Eaton Street  For Sale, MLS 586539
$674,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,220 SqFt Days Listed: 220
-3.02% ($21,000) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 11 Days Ago
Duplex - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Historic Key West Conch Cottage! Centrally located on the 1100 Block of Eaton St., you are within walking distance to Duval, Caroline, and the Historic Water Front. 2 bedrooms 2 bath with off street parking on Eglin Ln.

1025  Whitehead Street A For Sale, MLS 588860
$779,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 795 SqFt Days Listed: 58
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

THE ONLY FULLY TRANSIENT HOME CURRENTLY LISTED FOR UNDER $1,000,000. Suzys Parrot Perch is a charming apartment that is located in the heart of Old Town on the corner of two historic streets (Whitehead and Virginia) just steps from Duval and two blocks from the Southernmost Point. (Flamingo Crossing, the famous homemade Key West ice cream parlor, is just around the corner, La Te Da is a block away), and yet this cozy 795 square foot condo is perched on the second floor of a two-story building, with its own quiet balcony away from the hustle and bustle. TRANSIENT LICENSE! This condo is transiently licensed. 2019 gross annual income was $77,000 with a 6% Cap Rate, and still growing. This profitable property is being offered turnkey, and with all future reservations

630  Caroline Street  For Sale, MLS 586304
$795,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,176 SqFt Days Listed: 241
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: None

Prime location in the Old Town Key West Seaport area. This corner property is ready for updates and is centrally located near some of Key Wests finest homes, restaurants, and shops. Two story home with front porch, rear patio, and off street parking. Main level offers large foyer, living room, kitchen, two baths, bedroom, and dining area. Upper level has second bedroom. Ready for renovation in the heart of Old Town.

923  Fleming Street  For Sale, MLS 588715
$799,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,600 SqFt Days Listed: 69
-7.63% ($66,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 1 Day Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

A unique conch house hidden away on Fleming street. Situated on a fully fenced in lot, surrounded by lush tropical landscaping offering plenty of privacy and shaded areas to relax outdoors. This home features an open concept living area, beautiful wood ceilings and French doors to take you away to your private tropical garden setting. Two generous size bedrooms, 2 full baths and a large sleeping loft make for a comfortable Key West get away. Schedule your private tour now!

1012  Whitehead Street  For Sale, MLS 589536
$799,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,625 SqFt Days Listed: 22
-1.24% ($10,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 8 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

.....All you need is the house keys and you are ready to begin your Key West Lifestyle. The interior is stunning from the lovely flooring to the wall art to the furniture. The exterior of the building is in near perfect condition to match the interior. You will enjoy sitting on the front porch people watching or just sipping on your beverage of choice. The floor plan allows for a lock-out with its own entrance. This prime location features walking distance to the Southernmost Point, Hemingway House, The Key West Lighthouse, and you can walk to your favorite Old Town restaurants and attractions. This renovated property is being offered completely Turn Key! Schedule your private tour now! property is located in the valuable X flood zone..check out the 3D tour

1125  Southard Street  For Sale, MLS 587927
$799,500
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 734 SqFt Days Listed: 118
-4.76% ($40,000) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 3 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

In Key West, Old Town is where you want to be. New again...totally renovated, perfectly located 2bed/2.5bath ground-level home. The 734sf living space also features a rough-finished, attic-bonus room with window thats not included in square footage. All new infrastructure: kitchen and baths, new electric and plumbing and AC and floors because the circa 1880s almost-all-Dade-county pine house is updated with all the conveniences of a modern home. High ceilings, stainless appliances, granite counters, movable kitchen island, ceramic-tile baths and more finish details like crown molding with corner points. Even has a unique architectural staircase that accesses the attic from the wide hallway. Easy to show. Call agent.

327  Peacon Lane  For Sale, MLS 583634
$893,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,413 SqFt Days Listed: 409
-25.58% ($307,000) 5 Price Changes : Last Change 37 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: None

UNDER APPRAISED VALUE Located in X ZONE on prized Peacon Lane a stones throw from everything Key West. Never listed before the home has been in the family for many generations. This Eyebrow Home has been modified to provide more space and a wonderful second story 21 x 17 porch. The front yard has been bricked to allow parking, a premium in old town. The rear of the property is decked providing lots of space for outdoor entertaining. There is room for a small pool or spa.

531  Margaret Street  For Sale, MLS 589893
$895,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 936 SqFt Days Listed: 3
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

A wonderfully quaint and keezie home, nicely appointed throughout, open and airy with cathedral ceilings and its location, WOW, its in the best part of Old Town! Picture yourself relaxing on the front porch watching folks stroll by or hanging poolside at your large in-ground pool with generous deck or perhaps hanging out on the deck at the rear of your home. The master suite is located on the 2nd floor with its own private deck, bath and large closet. This beautiful home is well maintained with many updates throughout and is being offered turnkey.

716  Elizabeth Street  For Sale, MLS 589149
$995,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,488 SqFt Days Listed: 40
-9.13% ($100,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 3 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

So fresh and so clean, this Tropical Cottage boasts an X-Flood Zone address, and is on one of the best blocks in the Historic District of Key West. Enter through the white picket fence to find an updated single-level home featuring a lovely covered front porch, 3 Bedrooms (one currently setup as an office), Chefs Kitchen, tile floors, and a charming tranquil backyard with a beautiful water feature. Dont miss this opportunity to own a piece of Key West history with the amenities of modern day living!

516  Elizabeth Street  For Sale, MLS 589000
$1,149,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,411 SqFt Days Listed: 47
-9.88% ($126,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 9 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Listed on the National Register of Historic Places and awarded the Gold Star for Historic Preservations, 516 Elizabeth Street is the perfect example of a Classical Revival eyebrow home located in the X-Flood zone of Old Town, Key West and built prior to 1892. Eyebrow houses are a unique Key West architectural design consisting of a full two-story plan with the roof extending down over the second floor windows onto classic porch columns (giving these homes the moniker eyebrow) affording an ample amount of shade to the second story. Greeted by a quintessential Key West porch, step inside to discover plenty of Dade County Pine, 10ft. high ceilings, original double hung wooden windows, and a large backyard perfect for lounging and entertainment.

205  Virginia Street  For Sale, MLS 588197
$1,149,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,477 SqFt Days Listed: 103
-11.27% ($146,000) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 26 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

Key West living at its best. Brand new custom frame home meets 180MPH wind load with impact windows and doors for low insurance costs. Home offers 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, off-street parking and private swimming pool. A few blocks off Duval, walking distance to all that Key West has to offer. Just picture being the first owner of this fabulous property! Owners are licensed FL real estate agents.

726  Poor House Lane  For Sale, MLS 587718
$1,198,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,103 SqFt Days Listed: 135
-9.86% ($131,000) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 17 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Renovated 3/2 All new impact windows, Kitchen cabinets and countertops. Designed with an open floor plan. Located where 3 lanes converge next to Butler Pocket Park. Large 4800 sf old town corner lot. Off St. Parking with electronic gate. She Shed has also been updated. Nicely planted with lots of flowers, 2 guava, a lime. and a huge prolific avocado tree. Rear of house has very generous covered porch ideal for entertaining.

626  Margaret Street  For Sale, MLS 589123
$1,289,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,392 SqFt Days Listed: 42
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

This charming historic Conch home has nautical flair and a distinct Key West island luxury vibe. Featuring a classic front porch, a light filled interior complimented by exotic hardwoods, high ceilings, beautiful detail work, and a newly remodeled kitchen with high-end stainless appliances, pantry & seating area. Perfect for entertaining, the kitchen opens to the back patio, pool, and air-conditioned poolside cabana, featuring a wet bar and seating area that doubles as a pull-out sofa bed. A stained glass Buddha window greets you on the 2nd floor, which contains a large master suite with cathedral ceilings, abundant closet space, and a bonus room currently setup as an office. Theres also a guest bedroom that opens to a private rooftop terrace overlooking the pool.

612  White Street  For Sale, MLS 587708
$1,295,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,580 SqFt Days Listed: 135
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Truly a Key West classic home, this conch cottage was originally built circa 1889. Today this house looks very similar to its original roots on the outside, but the interior has been given quite a beautiful makeover. Recently renovated with appealing smart home features including home control systems, electronic door locks, and music throughout, youll be quickly comfortable and enjoying your home to the fullest. With a private pool and outdoor shower in the backyard adjacent to the large kitchen and family room, indoor and outdoor living flow easily for entertaining. There is also a bedroom, bathroom, living room with fireplace and office/laundry room on the first floor. The glass enclosed staircase leads to the second floor with master bedroom, bathroom and additional bedroom.

709  Whitehead Street  For Sale, MLS 588981
$1,300,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,308 SqFt Days Listed: 48
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Located in the heart of Old Town. This conch home is all about history and location. It has been passed down from generation to generation and could not be in a more ideal location. This three bedroom, two bathroom home is ready for new homeowners to move in and put their own special touch to it and create an Old Town masterpiece. It has plenty of indoor and outdoor space and is located in the X flood zone. There is off street parking for two cars and a charming front porch to spend hours people watching. You are one block from Duval Street and Bahama Village and walking distance to the Hemingway Home, Key West Lighthouse and Southernmost Point. You can walk and to all the best restaurants and galleries in Historic Old Town and really live the island lifestyle.

819  Whitehead Street  For Sale, MLS 589578
$1,375,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,211 SqFt Days Listed: 19
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Classic conch style cottage meets modern technology in this fully renovated 3 bedroom, 2 1/2 bathroom smart home. Situated in the highly desirable X flood zone. Perfect location just one block to famous Duval Street, within walking distance to many Key West attractions and restaurants and just a few blocks from the beaches and waterfront park.When done exploring for the day, relax in your private backyard garden, complete with lush landscaping, guest cottage, outdoor shower, Ipe deck, Chicago style brick patio, irrigation system, landscape lighting and custom storage.No expense was spared in the full renovation of this entire property. Completely gutted and reframed all 100% to Key West code and professional architect direction. Steel beams added per engineered specifications.

316  William Street  For Sale, MLS 589759
$1,495,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,436 SqFt Days Listed: 10
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Located on a picturesque Old Town street, in one of the most desirable areas of the historic seaport, sits this charming 2BD/2BA bungalow style home with a 1BD/1BA detached cottage. Originally built in 1860s it has been added onto and now has an open & light filled great room with French doors opening on to an a great entertainment deck built around a 12 x 24 pool. With plenty of room on the back deck area and outdoor covered media den, it is a low maintenance yard & the perfect island getaway. The choice is yours, a first floor bedroom or the entire 2nd floor is your master suite and bath. Enjoy a delightful front porch to sit back in your rocking chair, a key stone coral private patio tucked behind the guest house & accent coral pavers meandering through out the fully fenced yard. A car

714  Passover Lane  For Sale, MLS 589236
$1,536,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 1,888 SqFt Days Listed: 37
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

THIS PROPERTY COMES WITH 3 ROGOSExcellent opportunity to renovate a Historic Estate in the heart of Old-Town Key West. This property can be restored to a Grand Estate or a 3 unit compound with off street parking and ample room for expansion including a pool.

714  Passover Lane  For Sale, MLS 589235
$1,536,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 1,888 SqFt Days Listed: 37
Multi-Units - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

THIS PROPERTY COMES WITH 3 ROGOSExcellent opportunity to renovate a Historic Estate in the heart of Old-Town Key West.This property does have a curb-cut and can be restored to a Grand Estate or a 3 unit compound with ample room for expansion including a pool.

904  Terry Lane  For Sale, MLS 586069
$1,600,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 1,238 SqFt Days Listed: 257
Multi-Units - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

This multi-family residential home is comprised of 4 one bedroom, one bath condos. Condo conversion documents have been approved and in place. Great investment that allows for employees housing, monthly rentals or the ability to sell all of the units separately. Located in our historic Bahama Village within walking distance of Duval St. and all that Old Town has to offer. All units have been nicely renovated with attractive kitchens and baths, walk in closets and individual laundry units. The grounds are completely fenced, 4 off street parking spaces and private outdoor space for each unit.

908  Packer Street  For Sale, MLS 585234
$1,699,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 2,040 SqFt Days Listed: 313
-14.84% ($296,000) 9 Price Changes : Last Change 47 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Sophisticated Elegance will greet you as you enter this Beautiful Historic Home. Located just a short Stroll from the Action on Quiet block of Packer St. The property boasts an excellent layout which flows gracefully from the living room to the Stunning Kitchen and then opens to the vast pool and garden area. A downstairs Master is an enviable feature and an additional two bedrooms are located on the second floor. Incredible second floor deck and balcony offers a private lounge area and the sun filled deck is perfect to catch that summer tan. Stunning Lap pool surrounded by perfect sized deck with lots of space for outdoor dining and entertaining. With plenty of street parking available, this property is one of the special ones and must be seen to be appreciated.

1120  Curry Lane  For Sale, MLS 588099
$1,749,900
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,922 SqFt Days Listed: 108
-2.51% ($45,100) 1 Price Change : Last Change 1 Day Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Quintessential island life blocks from shore in Old Town restored Conch home with guest house! Maximize the outdoors with porch, balcony, and fenced yard with heated pool. Entertain in living area with hardwood flooring and ample windows for sunlight, updated kitchen with quartz countertop and tile floor. Enjoy open-air living and ocean breeze with French doors onto pool area. Dine on outdoor deck with ceiling fan. Main house with central air has 2 beds with balcony access, 3 full baths with stone flooring. Ideal for hosting in separate guest house with double-height ceiling, lofted sleeping area, service kitchen, private bath, split system unit. This versatile area can also be a media room, with pull-down screen and blackout shades. Park on 2 off-street spaces. Cant beat this gem!

804  Elizabeth Street  For Sale, MLS 586982
$1,999,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 2,046 SqFt Days Listed: 192
-8.72% ($191,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 46 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Quintessentially Key West, this inviting historic home is perfectly located in Old Town, two blocks from Duval, yet on a quiet one-way street. Park in one of the 3 off-street parking spaces and start your tour. Open the gate of the white picket fence onto the reclaimed brick path and walk up to the captivating porch to sit on rockers or sway on the swing and say hi to your neighbors as they stroll by. Enter the front door and be drawn by the glossy mahogany floors, light-filled living room, plantation shutters, and high ceilings. Sit on the couch and see straight through the house to the pool, so you can always be poolside, even when indoors. Wander into the spectacular dining room, wrapped in Dade County pine, graced with a vaulted ceiling and a custom chandelier thats sure to start

414  William Street  For Sale, MLS 589580
$2,000,000
Key West
Old Town Unlisted - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 2,050 SqFt Days Listed: 19
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Beautifully restored 3BD/3.5BA home located on one of the most desirable and pristine blocks of William Street with over 2,000 sq. ft. of living space and sitting on nearly a 3,000 sq ft. lot. Located just steps away from the Key West Historic Seaport and Duval Street, fine dining, art galleries and museums. Striking Dade County pine walls give the home its historic old world charm. On the first floor is a formal living room, desirable en suite bedroom, powder room, tastefully appointed kitchen with gorgeous quartz counter tops along with a butlers station and Wolf gas appliances. Adjoining the kitchen is the dining room with Palladian arched windows and French doors allowing for plenty of natural lights. Out back you can find your covered dining area and pool surrounded by tropical

Most Recent Sales - (122) - Old Town - Unlisted as of 2020-02-22
Sale Date Address Sale Price $/SF List Price Sq. Ft. Type Bd/Ba Days Listed
02-14-2020 527 Fleming $2,400,000 $769 $2,675,000 3,120 Multi-Units 4/4 173
02-07-2020 1109 Olivia $965,000 $858 $999,000 1,124 Single Family 2/2 68
02-06-2020 1122 Stump $400,000 $869 $449,000 460 Single Family 1/1 18
02-06-2020 1120 Stump $500,000 $625 $599,000 800 Single Family 2/1 18
02-03-2020 711 Elizabeth $1,175,000 $901 $1,300,000 1,304 Single Family 2/2 126
01-30-2020 732 Windsor $710,000 $657 $725,000 1,080 Single Family 2/2 257
01-07-2020 522 Petronia $1,060,000 $607 $1,249,000 1,744 Single Family 3/2 39
12-27-2019 719 Bakers $490,000 $544 $499,000 900 Single Family 2/2 81
12-16-2019 523 Elizabeth $1,000,000 $533 $1,000,000 1,874 Single Family 3/2 1
12-13-2019 308 Margaret 6 $465,000 $1,150 $499,000 404 Single Family 1/1 211
12-13-2019 1023 Southard $800,000 $604 $800,000 1,323 Single Family 2/2 1
12-06-2019 613 Virginia $860,000 $603 $875,000 1,425 Townhouse 3/3 59
12-06-2019 609 Virginia $863,000 $605 $863,000 1,425 Townhouse 2/3 36
12-05-2019 319 Julia $630,000 $533 $699,000 1,181 Duplex 4/3 116
11-25-2019 904 Truman $620,000 $539 $620,000 1,150 Multi-Units 3/3 85
11-22-2019 812 Olivia $680,000 $503 $720,000 1,351 Single Family 2/1 32
11-22-2019 738 Poor House $715,000 $777 $725,000 920 Single Family 2/2 114
11-06-2019 1101 Fleming $854,000 $1,106 $879,000 772 Single Family 2/2 17
11-06-2019 729 Love $1,425,000 $678 $1,549,000 2,101 Single Family 3/2 226
10-31-2019 1017 Southard $4,999,000 $1,187 $4,999,000 4,208 Single Family 5/5 365
10-16-2019 808 Olivia $1,275,000 $713 $1,275,000 1,786 Single Family 3/3 1
09-20-2019 328 Simonton $1,750,000 $599 $1,750,000 2,920 Multi-Units 3/2 1
09-18-2019 727 Love $1,200,000 $735 $1,295,000 1,631 Single Family 3/2 100
09-09-2019 416 Margaret $1,450,000 $901 $1,599,000 1,609 Single Family 3/3 476
08-28-2019 217 Truman $637,000 $623 $649,000 1,022 Single Family 2/2 198
08-16-2019 2 Hutchinson $520,000 $623 $520,000 834 Single Family 2/1 2
08-07-2019 515 Louisa $1,700,000 $1,080 $1,700,000 1,574 Single Family 4/4 55
08-02-2019 1022 Fleming $1,150,000 $570 $1,299,000 2,016 Duplex 4/2 212
07-31-2019 520 Louisa $935,000 $485 $995,000 1,924 Multi-Units 5/4 44
07-30-2019 808 Shavers $1,190,000 $850 $1,245,000 1,400 Single Family 2/2 68
07-25-2019 916 Thomas $1,500,000 $998 $1,645,000 1,502 Single Family 2/2 70
07-18-2019 215 Whitehead $1,450,000 $892 $1,590,000 1,624 Single Family 3/3 193
07-16-2019 1005 Eaton $700,000 $494 $745,000 1,415 Duplex 3/3 64
07-16-2019 512 Emma $2,225,000 $1,352 $2,400,000 1,645 Single Family 4/4 75
07-16-2019 52 Front $3,295,000 $982 $3,295,000 3,353 Single Family 5/6 1
07-01-2019 410 Catherine $1,220,000 $877 $1,285,000 1,391 Single Family 3/3 167
06-28-2019 710 Caroline $588,525 $261 $624,900 2,250 Single Family 6/4 162
06-28-2019 409 Catherine $805,000 $936 $795,000 860 Single Family 2/2 68
06-19-2019 54 Front $2,637,500 $872 $2,950,000 3,024 Single Family 3/3 117
06-14-2019 216 Fleming $1,115,000 $849 $1,199,000 1,312 Single Family 2/2 105
06-12-2019 330 Julia $2,350,000 $484 $2,599,000 4,849 Multi-Units 4/3 258
06-07-2019 911 Virginia $649,000 $687 $674,000 944 Single Family 2/2 124
06-07-2019 1119 Olivia $823,000 $681 $859,000 1,207 Duplex 3/2 143
06-07-2019 1026 James $1,275,000 $692 $1,319,000 1,842 Single Family 3/3 210
06-07-2019 1011 Eaton $1,925,000 $884 $1,995,000 2,176 Single Family 4/3 123
05-31-2019 1125 Southard $409,500 $557 $499,900 734 Single Family 1/1 63
05-28-2019 1017 Thomas $695,000 $755 $699,000 920 Single Family 3/3 274
05-24-2019 411 William 16 $450,000 $1,355 $499,000 332 Condotel 1/1 119
05-23-2019 520 Grinnell $782,250 $566 $800,000 1,382 Single Family 2/2 59
05-17-2019 909 Southard $597,000 $500 $614,900 1,194 Single Family 2/1 134
05-15-2019 526 William 5 $640,000 $766 $674,900 835 Condo 2/2 124
05-08-2019 915 Cornish $970,000 $961 $999,500 1,009 Single Family 2/2 317
05-06-2019 281 Trumbo 203 $2,255,000 $790 $2,349,000 2,851 Condo 3/3 88
05-01-2019 415 Julia $983,900 $544 $998,800 1,808 Duplex 3/4 127
04-30-2019 416 Amelia 1 $605,000 $827 $610,000 731 Single Family 2/1 405
04-30-2019 721 Love $875,000 $748 $875,000 1,169 Single Family 2/2 36
04-29-2019 409 Grinnell $1,200,000 $710 $1,249,000 1,688 Single Family 4/2 127
04-26-2019 1200 Whitehead $1,351,000 $350 $912,000 3,859 Single Family 3/3 42
04-25-2019 302 Amelia $1,300,000 $625 $1,349,000 2,080 Single Family 3/2 110
04-18-2019 1030 Fleming $1,975,000 $708 $1,999,000 2,787 Single Family 4/3 177
04-17-2019 1215 South $865,000 $792 $879,000 1,092 Single Family 2/2 146
04-15-2019 709 Whitmarsh $1,180,000 $298 $1,500,000 3,956 Multi-Units 7/8 98
04-04-2019 710 Bakers $745,000 $705 $899,000 1,056 Single Family 1/1 123
03-28-2019 1206 Watson $580,000 $358 $649,000 1,616 Single Family 4/1 228
03-20-2019 1125 Whitehead $535,000 $724 $565,000 738 Single Family 2/1 168
03-05-2019 903 Southard $715,000 $1,203 $729,000 594 Single Family 2/1 48
02-15-2019 615 Amelia $829,000 $577 $829,000 1,436 Townhouse 2/2 32
02-08-2019 4 Gecko $1,257,500 $1,113 $1,390,000 1,129 Single Family 3/3 250
01-28-2019 511 Frances $1,915,000 $1,098 $1,995,000 1,743 Single Family 3/3 50
01-25-2019 6 Hutchinson $629,000 $838 $659,000 750 Single Family 1/1 178
01-15-2019 508 Virginia $2,000,000 $876 $2,195,000 2,281 Single Family 3/3 72
01-07-2019 916 White $548,000 $634 $569,000 864 Single Family 2/1 147
01-03-2019 1110 Olivia $630,000 $1,000 $635,000 630 Single Family 1/1 66
12-28-2018 733 Poorhouse $625,000 $616 $649,000 1,013 Single Family 2/1 54
12-27-2018 723 Fleming $3,050,000 $870 $3,295,000 3,502 Single Family 4/3 64
11-30-2018 515 Margaret REAR $900,000 $746 $900,000 1,206 Single Family 2/1 164
11-21-2018 514 Porter $840,000 $875 $879,900 960 Townhouse 2/2 109
11-05-2018 726 Poor House $887,500 $693 $920,000 1,280 Single Family 3/2 189
10-30-2018 649 William $850,000 $343 $1,400,000 2,475 Multi-Units 6/6 246
10-24-2018 524 Margaret 101 $370,000 $1,000 $379,900 370 Condo /1 41
10-19-2018 1021 Fleming $1,425,000 $1,060 $1,475,000 1,344 Single Family 2/2 96
10-17-2018 228 Truman $614,000 $769 $614,000 798 Single Family 2/2 43
10-17-2018 1109 Petronia $640,000 $640 $649,000 1,000 Duplex 2/2 312
09-14-2018 829 Eaton $2,085,000 $807 $2,200,000 2,581 Single Family 4/4 89
09-10-2018 704 Eaton $2,700,000 $1,363 $2,600,000 1,980 Single Family 3/3 26
09-04-2018 618 White $690,000 $679 $750,000 1,015 Single Family 2/1 385
08-29-2018 723 Southard $960,000 $872 $985,000 1,100 Single Family 2/2 112
08-23-2018 712 Ashe $1,515,100 $1,150 $1,515,000 1,317 Single Family 3/2 36
08-09-2018 615 Virginia $770,000 $540 $790,000 1,425 Townhouse 2/3 97
08-07-2018 514 Louisa $549,000 $762 $549,000 720 Single Family 2/1 162
08-03-2018 742 Windsor $900,000 $676 $959,000 1,331 Duplex 3/3 226
07-31-2018 312 Margaret $829,000 $432 $829,000 1,916 Single Family 3/2 30
07-24-2018 1029 Simonton $800,000 $538 $815,000 1,485 Townhouse 3/3 44
07-09-2018 715 Fleming $775,000 $681 $849,000 1,137 Single Family 2/2 117
07-02-2018 313 Catherine 5 $299,000 $819 $329,000 365 Single Family 1/1 43
06-29-2018 825 Southard REAR $570,000 $791 $575,000 720 Single Family 1/2 39
06-22-2018 1018 James $550,000 $364 $639,000 1,510 Single Family 3/1 117
06-21-2018 917 Southard $1,050,000 $406 $1,195,000 2,583 Single Family 3/3 171
06-21-2018 626 Margaret $1,145,000 $822 $1,189,000 1,392 Single Family 2/1 88
06-12-2018 615 Grinnell 2 $1,250,000 $870 $1,299,999 1,436 Single Family 3/3 96
06-04-2018 1112 Elgin $800,000 $634 $859,000 1,260 Single Family 2/2 601
06-02-2018 1019 Simonton 103 $795,000 $529 $809,000 1,501 Townhouse 3/3 1399
05-25-2018 412 Grinnell $1,999,000 $1,064 $1,999,000 1,877 Single Family 4/4 70
05-21-2018 921 Whitehead $1,500,000 $498 $1,595,000 3,009 Single Family 4/4 219
05-17-2018 609 Angela $1,350,000 $618 $1,449,000 2,181 Single Family 4/2 144
05-14-2018 120 Angela 202 $662,500 $777 $689,000 852 Condo 2/2 49
05-14-2018 728 Elizabeth 1-3 $935,000 $391 $949,000 2,388 Multi-Units 3/4 279
05-07-2018 713 Emma 2 $660,000 $570 $699,000 1,156 Condo 2/2 106
04-25-2018 1013 Southard $1,635,000 $961 $1,695,000 1,701 Single Family 3/2 176
04-24-2018 917 Watson $525,000 $500 $699,000 1,050 Single Family 3/2 57
04-16-2018 219 Whitehead $1,875,000 $711 $2,199,000 2,637 Duplex 5/4 71
04-11-2018 420 Grinnell $1,960,000 $993 $1,990,000 1,972 Single Family 4/4 37
04-10-2018 833 Elizabeth $898,000 $431 $898,000 2,083 Duplex 5/4 92
04-06-2018 815 Sawyers $960,000 $700 $999,000 1,370 Single Family 3/2 73
03-30-2018 1014 Truman 3 $370,000 $363 $399,000 1,017 Condo 2/2 383
03-30-2018 1 Havana $1,220,000 $1,198 $1,295,000 1,018 Single Family 2/2 72
03-30-2018 808 Windsor $2,400,000 $776 $2,495,000 3,092 Single Family 4/4 443
03-29-2018 607 Virginia $750,000 $515 $849,000 1,455 Townhouse 2/3 1295
03-20-2018 916 Thomas $1,200,000 $837 $1,299,000 1,432 Single Family 2/1 98
03-02-2018 611 Virginia $755,000 $502 $825,000 1,501 Townhouse 3/3 1310
03-02-2018 1021 Simonton $810,000 $562 $899,000 1,440 Townhouse 3/3 1172
02-22-2018 613 Virginia $790,000 $542 $799,000 1,455 Townhouse 3/3 1260
Thinking about selling your Old Town - Unlisted home?

Get a free no obligation home value report and know your home's value, even if you are just curious. If you decide to sell or are considering it, our company specializes in selling homes in your community and we can provide you with the guidance on the process that will generate the most return on your investment. Inquire below for a free comparative market analysis of your property. All communication is private and no obligation.

Provide us with some quick details so we can setup a free no obligation and confidential phone call.


The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 02-22-2020.

Broker's Edge Realty
92300 Overseas Hwy Suite 303
Key Largo, Florida 33070

1(800) 692-3605
Contact Us