Old Town ~ Unrecord Properties for Sale in Key West, FL

Researching this community? View previous sales at Old Town - Unrecord. Let one our Keys area experts help you out.

Total Listings 68
Order By:

900  White Street 1 For Sale, MLS 588978
$485,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 718 SqFt Days Listed: 43
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Come take a look at this move-in ready, one bedroom, one bath condo in a authentic 1928 Craftsman bungalow that was converted into three condominium units. Large open kitchen with custom cabinetry and quartz countertop leads to open an living/dining plan with natural shiplap walls throughout. Large bedroom with an extra bonus room to be used as an office, sitting area or bedroom. Lots of storage. Private driveway with access to side entry also includes a covered private patio area. The front yard is also a limited comment element to this unit only.New central ac being installed, washer/dryer, low condo fees,and more. Bike or walk to all you favorite Old Town attractions. Dont miss this one!

2  Nassau Lane 1 For Sale, MLS 586355
$499,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 554 SqFt Days Listed: 231
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Updated, luxury 1 bed, 1 bath condo in Old Town just off Fleming Street. The condo features stainless appliances, granite counter tops and beautiful hardwood flooring just walking distance to the Historic Seaport. Enjoy a spacious master bedroom that overlooks the charming, covered patio. Working capital contribution equivalent to two months condo fee due at closing. Sellers attorney, Greg Oropeza, to close all transaction and provide title insurance policy.

604  Truman Avenue 3 For Sale, MLS 583762
$499,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 754 SqFt Days Listed: 398
-9.11% ($50,000) 5 Price Changes : Last Change 10 Days Ago
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Pictures taken prior to tenant moving in. Located in the heart of old town in walking distance to great restaurants and is truly a gem. There is a balcony overlooking Truman Ave for people watching. Walk up a spiral staircase that lands you in the middle of the upstairs where the spacious bedroom. On each side of this bedroom area you can make a sleeping quarters on one side and a dressing/sitting area not he other side. The bathroom, living room, kitchenette is downstairs setup on an open floor plan. Laminate wood floors throughout. Window AC units. There is no washer or dryer but a laundry mat is one block away with drop off service. This unit comes with one assigned parking space.

324  Virginia Street  For Sale, MLS 587608
$545,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,122 SqFt Days Listed: 135
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Lowest price single family home in Old Town (in MLS). Priced at $486 per sq ft. The next house thats at least 1100 sq ft on lot that is at least 3300 sq ft is priced $385,000 MORE! Close to many attractions & just 1.5 blocks off Duval St. Excellent opportunity to own a quintessential conch house that beckons to be returned to its former glory. Strip away the layers of paint & drywall to reveal the splendor of abundant interior wood (believed to be Dade Co Pine). Current configuration has total of 9 rooms & most boast high ceilings. Back yard has room for pool. Off street parking possible. Property requires major renovation. This is an estate sale. Property being sold As Is w/ no repair & no clean up by sellers. City of KW Planning Dep has recognized 2nd market rate building right.

2  Nassau Lane 3 For Sale, MLS 588202
$549,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 661 SqFt Days Listed: 97
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Updated, luxury 1 bed, 1 bath condo in Old Town just off Fleming Street. This second-story condo features stainless appliances, granite counter tops and beautiful hardwood floors just walking distance to the Historic Seaport. Tiled bathroom with shower/tub combo accessible from the master and living room. Enjoy a sunny balcony overlooking peaceful Nassau Lane. Working capital contribution equivalent to two months condo fee due at closing. Sellers attorney, Greg Oropeza, to close all transaction and provide title insurance policy.

1112  Stickney Lane  For Sale, MLS 588980
$569,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 614 SqFt Days Listed: 43
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

This Old Town gem is ready for a lucky person! Located at the end of an Old Town lane with two, covered off-street parking spaces - a coveted luxury in Old Town, its been dolled up to please and also to maximize a fully fenced outdoor living / garden area that includes an electric gate to parking. This quintessential cottage proves the adage that good things really do come in small packages! In addition to the pictures, please be sure and view the immersive tour of the home. Although there is an HOA, its inactive; it includes two fully separate homes that share a common fence. No fees. No meetings.

1126  Stump Lane  For Sale, MLS 588897
$589,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 591 SqFt Days Listed: 49
-1.67% ($10,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 13 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: None

Great Old Town Conch Cottage, on a wonderful quiet lane. This home was restored around 2005, with new piers ,electric,plumbing, some flooring, and more. The dade pine walls were sanded, and clear coated. There is a vaulted ceiling in the living room, a spa tub in the bathroom, and newer Azec decking outside. French doors off of the living room lead to a private wonderful seating area, outdoor shower, and a storage shed.

2  Nassau Lane 2 For Sale, MLS 588203
$599,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 744 SqFt Days Listed: 97
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Updated, luxury 2 bed, 1.5 bath condo in Old Town just off Fleming Street. The condo features stainless appliances, granite counter tops and beautiful hardwood floors just walking distance to the Historic Seaport. The bedrooms share a jack-and-jill, tiled bathroom with shower/tub combo. Both rooms have french doors that lead to the private, fenced patio space. Working capital contribution equivalent to two months condo fee due at closing. Sellers attorney, Greg Oropeza, to close all transaction and provide title insurance policy.

2  Nassau Lane 4 For Sale, MLS 588201
$599,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 699 SqFt Days Listed: 97
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Updated, luxury 1 bed, 1 bath condo in Old Town just off Fleming Street. The condo features stainless appliances, granite counter tops and beautiful hardwood flooring just walking distance to the Historic Seaport. Enjoy cathedral ceilings, treetop views an open floor plan with skylights and bonus room. French doors off the living room and master lead to the peaceful, private balcony. Working capital contribution equivalent to two months condo fee due at closing. Sellers attorney, Greg Oropeza, to close all transaction and provide title insurance policy.

703  Windsor Lane  For Sale, MLS 585136
$608,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 808 SqFt Days Listed: 315
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Nice 1 bedroom 1 bath located in Old Town tucked away on a quiet walk way with tropical foliage just blocks from downtown. This property does not have a yard or its own parking spot, however parking is available on the street. Very private location. Call Listing agent for more details.

611  Grinnell Street 4 For Sale, MLS 586729
$624,997
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 784 SqFt Days Listed: 201
-0.00% ($3) 1 Price Change : Last Change 118 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Flood Zone X-Charming Conch cottage in a gated compound, surrounded by a large sunny pool encompassed by mature native shade trees. This home is located in the desirable neighborhood of Old Town North, which features everything that is quintessential Key West - architecture, shopping, nightlife and culture. Located 4 blocks from the Historic Seaport and midway between the world famous Five Brothers Coffee Shop and 5 star restaurants, this home is off the beaten path but does not lack for proximity to entertainment. When you are ready for some relaxation, take a dip in the virtually private pool. New roof added in April of 2019, three new mini AC splits and fresh exterior paint make this home move-in ready! Location-Location!

813  Whitehead Street  For Sale, MLS 589724
$649,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 976 SqFt Days Listed: 7
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Fantastic renovation opportunity for this quintessential, classic Key West Home. The opportunities are endless to make this your dream home or investment. Large backyard offers room for pool, bungalow, storage. Open front porch makes for the perfect people watching spot in busy downtown. Metal roof in place. Just steps from Duval Street, the famous Green Parrot and Hemingway House.

1124  Eaton Street  For Sale, MLS 585213
$774,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,288 SqFt Days Listed: 309
-3.13% ($25,000) 3 Price Changes : Last Change 40 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Inviting turn-key cottage located in Old Town. Gorgeous hardwood floors, updated kitchen with granite counter tops, nice large built-in cabinets, open floor plan with large seated bar. Modern updated bathrooms. Major plus with off street parking! If you love Key West cottages, this is the home youve been looking for! Recent additions include a Dream maker hot tub spa and comes completely furnished! Exterior painting just finished. Schedule a showing today and make this your Key West home or vacation spot!

224  Olivia Street  For Sale, MLS 588334
$779,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,135 SqFt Days Listed: 89
-11.48% ($101,000) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 19 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

224 Olivia St has been completely remodeled and is move in ready ! Fenced-in yard, nicely designed landscaping with new irrigation system, front porch, and off street parking for 2 cars. This sunny 3 bedroom 2 bath home has an additional cottage that could also be used as an office or artist studio. Located just a few blocks away from the best shopping, entertainment and dining on Duval St . The Hemingway house, Fort Zachary Taylor Beach, Key West Ampitheatre, and The Southermost Point are all a short walk or bike ride from 224 Olivia St. Schedule your private tour today!

907  Frances Street  For Sale, MLS 588489
$835,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,056 SqFt Days Listed: 77
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Charming conch cottage ,c 1884.A former recipient of the Historic Florida Keys Foundation Preservation Award after its renovation in the early 90s, this home is still in wonderful condition today. The main house has one bedroom and bath with an eat in kitchen, nice size living room, Dade pine walls, ceilings and floors, and lovely casement windows in the kitchen plus central air. Theres a separate cottage, (which used to be a general mercantile store back in the day) with a second bedroom and bath. Established plantings and a brick patio under a shady tree make this home ideal for outdoor enjoyment.

1013  Truman Avenue  For Sale, MLS 588057
$869,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,440 SqFt Days Listed: 105
Duplex - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Extremely handsome mixed-use building, a true Key West Classic. Wonderfully renovated in 1997, the commercial unit downstairs has 1BD/ 1.5BA and a full kitchen. Upstairs is a 1 bedroom, 1 bath apartment w/ a huge outdoor back deck & relaxing front porch. Covered off-street parking in the rear of the building or use the space as a back yard. There is a huge 864sf unfinished storage attic that for the creative out there would be an excellent project. Centrally located on Truman Avenue, this building is also zoned HNC-1 which is a transient license receivership area, giving even more potential to a future project. Tons of historic charm!

904  James Street  For Sale, MLS 588088
$875,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 2,250 SqFt Days Listed: 104
-5.41% ($50,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 25 Days Ago
Multi-Units - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Great Location! Walk to the action and the Harbor. This is an income producing property with 3 rental units; units A & C are one bed/one bath on the ground level and Unit B is a two bed/one bath located on the 2nd floor.

820  Carsten Lane  For Sale, MLS 589165
$879,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
1 Bed, 1 Baths, 612 SqFt Days Listed: 35
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Quaint Key West cottage conveniently located in Old Town between Margaret Street and William Street on Carsten Lane. This one bedroom, one bath home features hardwood floors and Dade County pine walls. French doors open to the living room and allow the outdoors in. The laundry area is just off the kitchen and bath. There is a large first floor porch with plenty of room for entertaining that opens to the private rear yard with heated, saltwater pool. A rear gate takes you to Carey Lane. Large covered second floor porch offers plenty of outdoor living and entertaining while overlooking the rear yard and pool from the treetops.

1401  Simonton Street 23 For Sale, MLS 585696
$900,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 907 SqFt Days Listed: 278
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

Stunning Income Producing Resort Condominium in Old Town Key West. Rated #4 out of 51 Hotels in Key West on Trip Advisor. One Block From Famous Duval Street! This 2 Bedroom and 2.5 Bath Contemporary Luxury Condominium Includes A Rarely Offered City Of Key West Transient Rental License that Allows For Nightly Vacation Rentals That Produces Excellent Income. The Main Level Has a Stylish Gourmet Kitchen, 2 Balconies, One Overlooking The Pool, Living Area and a Powder Room. Upper Level Has 2 Bedrooms With Designer Baths and Balcony with Pool Views. Enjoy Key Wests Finest Sushi On Site At Ambrosia Japanese Restaurant. Amenities Include 2 Heated Pools, Lush Tropical Grounds, Beach Access With Beach Chairs, Umbrellas,Towels,24 Hour Concierge, Parking and Fitness Room.

534  Margaret Street  For Sale, MLS 589404
$948,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,848 SqFt Days Listed: 23
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Located on a beautiful corner lot at the intersection of Margaret & Southard in one of the most desirable areas of residential Old Town Key West. This grand 3BD/3BA home has high ceilings throughout, a spacious downstairs great room with separate living and dining areas, and a full bathroom on the main level. The kitchen has granite countertops, stainless appliances & lots of space for cooking & storage. The upstairs has a master suite with attached bonus room, perfect for an office or studio. Two guest bedrooms and a shared bathroom complete the second level. Low maintenance yard. Walking distance to the Historic Seaport, Duval St, and many of the restaurants, shops & attractions of Key West.

814  Windsor Lane  For Sale, MLS 589069
$949,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,350 SqFt Days Listed: 40
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Rare opportunity in Old-Town to build on the existing structure or clear the lot to start from scratch. Large corner lot with beautiful vegetation and plenty of room for a swimming pool and off-street parking. The existing house is obviously habitable, yet will not qualify for conventional financing. This project is perfect for an investor, snow bird or local resident whose vision is to build a legacy home, meeting new industry and environmental standards.

408  Amelia Street  For Sale, MLS 588151
$969,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,213 SqFt Days Listed: 101
-2.86% ($28,500) 1 Price Change : Last Change 48 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Impeccable 3 bedroom, 2 bath home located in the center Old Town has been completely renovated.These improvements include a new kitchen with stainless steel appliances, bamboo and tiled floors, new bathrooms, central a/c and new windows. Enjoy single level living with a convenient open floor plan, cathedral ceilings and charming pine walls . There is a separate room which can be used as an office, or den with French doors leading out to your inviting deck & hot tub. This terrific opportunity is also fully fenced for privacy, Very easy to show! This home has been a popular vacation rental.

5  Hunts Lane  For Sale, MLS 589279
$969,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,210 SqFt Days Listed: 29
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Location, Location, Location. Located on a quiet walking lane off Southard St (across from 916 Southard) this wonderfully rebuilt home has it all. Totally reconstructed in 2010 from the piers to the roof with so many upgrades (see additional documents). History abounds with 5 tongue and groove natural Dade County Pine walls and stained glass fixtures upstairs and downstairs. Custom hand built stairs lead to two bedrooms and two bathrooms with instant hot water. Fabulous kitchen includes granite counters, two tone upgraded cabinetry, stainless appliances and many more. If you are looking for a very low maintenance property in the heart of Old Town this wonderfully rebuilt home is the one. Call for a private showing and make this home your own Piece of Paradise!

207  Virginia Street  For Sale, MLS 587807
$995,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,344 SqFt Days Listed: 123
-13.40% ($154,000) 2 Price Changes : Last Change 20 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

Key West living at its best . Brand new custom frame home meets 180MPH wind load with impact windows and doors for low insurance costs. Home offers 2 bedrooms, 2 baths, off-street parking and private swimming pool. Entire second floor is the spacious master suite featuring a large walk-in closet. Master bath offers a stand alone shower with rain shower head and a soaking tub. A few blocks off Duval walking distance to all that Key West has to offer. Just picture being the first owner of this fabulous property!Owners are licensed FL real estate agents.

923  Southard Street  For Sale, MLS 586060
$1,074,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,476 SqFt Days Listed: 252
-10.43% ($125,000) 3 Price Changes : Last Change 10 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Enjoy this classic 2 bd/2ba Key West home encompassing a rare combination of location and character. Boasting historic charm, the entry welcomes you inside with surroundings of Dade County pine and wood flooring throughout with natural lighting flowing all around. The main floor offers a large living space with an adjoining full bathroom with a beautiful claw foot tub. The bright kitchen overlooks the lush and private backyard which begs for entertaining. Follow the original wood staircase to the second level to find two bedrooms with the master having an ensuite full bathroom and a rear deck overlooking this serene sanctuary. Outdoor living with plentiful deck space, a heated dip pool and backdrop of tropical landscaping make this a quintessential destination to savor island life!

311  Amelia Street  For Sale, MLS 582189
$1,075,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 2,105 SqFt Days Listed: 501
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Located in the heart of Old Town, this 3 bedroom 3 bath home features many updates.

506  Elizabeth Street  For Sale, MLS 586008
$1,149,900
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,292 SqFt Days Listed: 256
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

When a rich history combines with modern construction and award-winning architecture, the result is a rare work of art. This three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bathroom home is located in the best part of Old Town Key West. Originally built in the 1800s, it was subjected to a ground-up and extremely high-quality renovation. The homeshistory was kept intact whenever possible, including leaving part of the originalwallpaper. When it came to the structure, modern conveniences, beauty, and functionality, all were improved and rebuilt to the highest standards. Located walking distance to the best of Key West, but still has off street parking.

1401  Simonton Street 5 For Sale, MLS 587213
$1,170,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 958 SqFt Days Listed: 167
Condo - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

Great opportunity to own a single level low Suite 2 bedroom two bath condo at the exclusive Santa Maria resorts. This condo is a end unit and is located half a block from the famous Duval Street in Key West. The condo has a transit rental license with excellent rental history and is a great income producing investment. Santa Maria is rated in the top five resorts in Key West and has the best sushi restaurant on the island. Key West finest condo resort living with all resort amenities including beach access to the reach resort.

315  Catherine Street A For Sale, MLS 588913
$1,199,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,233 SqFt Days Listed: 48
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

This premier, new CAT 5 construction town home, built 7 ft. above base flood, is the Great Old Town location you want. This very desirable 3 bedrooms/2.5 baths layout features a downstairs Master, Hardie Board siding and impact windows & doors. This is signature Key West living with an open floor plan that opens onto a lovely deck area with a private, heated pool and water feature. The off street parking for 1 car and a fenced yard further complements this quiet, Historic District location where youll enjoy strolls to the new Truman Waterfront. Classic and elegant with oak flooring, quartz counter-tops, stainless appliances and beautiful stone baths. Furniture package also available upon request. Nest front door, security system and WiFi and smart rain bird sprinkler.

313  Truman Avenue  For Sale, MLS 582558
$1,199,000
Key West
Old Town Unrecord - MM: 1.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,548 SqFt Days Listed: 474
-12.80% ($176,000) 6 Price Changes : Last Change 12 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Live the charmed life of the old days in this classic Key West home. Its renovation immortalized its past while infusing the present with charm and comfort. This lovely home offers three en suite bedrooms with one on the main floor. Other features include a generous open kitchen, Dade County wood interior, custom staircases, soaring ceilings and off-street covered parking. French doors off the upstairs bedroom lead out to a spacious terrace that overlooks The Key West Light House grounds. The garden pool area is located just below for private entertaining with a large front porch for relaxing and the list goes on.. On a quiet, one-way street, it is conveniently located a short block off Duval Street near the Ernest Hemingway Home and the Southernmost Point. This home is sure to please.

Most Recent Sales - (136) - Old Town - Unrecord as of 2020-02-17
Sale Date Address Sale Price $/SF List Price Sq. Ft. Type Bd/Ba Days Listed
02-07-2020 506 Emma $1,747,000 $1,086 $1,825,000 1,608 Townhouse 3/3 117
01-29-2020 826 Olivia $560,000 $775 $585,000 722 Single Family 1/1 237
01-24-2020 520 Porter $897,000 $934 $929,000 960 Townhouse 2/2 117
01-15-2020 524 White $975,000 $576 $998,500 1,690 Single Family 3/2 63
01-07-2020 814 Whitehead $644,000 $546 $649,000 1,178 Duplex 3/3 43
12-18-2019 715 Thomas $920,000 $521 $975,000 1,763 Single Family 2/2 393
12-05-2019 1119 Whitehead $1,300,000 $722 $1,360,000 1,800 Single Family 3/2 94
12-02-2019 904 Olivia $1,100,000 $969 $1,195,000 1,135 Single Family 2/2 197
11-22-2019 1210 Packer $685,000 $256 $725,000 2,675 Multi-Units 5/5 304
11-15-2019 106 Admirals $1,300,000 $802 $1,395,000 1,620 Townhouse 2/2 262
11-15-2019 116 Admirals $1,855,700 $956 $2,195,000 1,940 Single Family 4/3 171
11-14-2019 622 Ashe $1,220,000 $773 $1,298,000 1,578 Single Family 3/2 139
10-23-2019 624 White $1,200,000 $878 $1,200,000 1,366 Single Family 3/2 92
10-08-2019 320 Admirals $3,100,000 $1,241 $3,300,000 2,496 Single Family 4/4 191
10-03-2019 823 Elizabeth $1,125,000 $1,163 $1,125,000 967 Single Family 3/2 1
09-17-2019 317 William $770,000 $396 $799,000 1,944 Duplex 3/3 105
09-11-2019 711 Olivia $1,695,000 $1,126 $1,795,000 1,504 Single Family 3/3 69
09-06-2019 716 Thomas $825,000 $613 $849,500 1,344 Single Family 3/2 213
09-03-2019 900 White 2 $562,000 $536 $599,000 1,048 Condo 3/2 114
08-30-2019 419 William 6 $275,000 $851 $315,000 323 Condo /1 351
08-23-2019 11 Hutchinson 4 $905,000 $805 $965,000 1,123 Single Family 2/2 99
08-23-2019 1115 Southard $1,000,000 $658 $1,000,000 1,518 Single Family 3/3 264
08-15-2019 719 Thomas $1,925,000 $783 $2,195,000 2,457 Single Family 4/4 43
07-26-2019 400 White $785,000 $425 $799,900 1,845 Single Family 3/2 108
07-16-2019 626 Fleming B $585,000 $461 $624,900 1,268 Townhouse 3/2 89
07-12-2019 1116 Eaton $535,000 $714 $579,000 749 Single Family 2/1 305
06-21-2019 807 Whitehead $725,000 $391 $799,999 1,854 Multi-Units 5/2 151
06-11-2019 720 Elizabeth 2 $500,000 $1,014 $525,000 493 Single Family 1/1 58
05-31-2019 809 Whitehead $860,000 $766 $899,900 1,122 Single Family 3/2 478
05-29-2019 607 & 609 Ashe $1,500,000 $773 $1,600,000 1,940 Duplex 3/3 87
05-29-2019 607 & 609 Ashe $1,500,000 $773 $1,600,000 1,940 Single Family 3/3 87
05-23-2019 1007 Thomas $350,000 $395 $384,000 884 Single Family 2/1 57
05-22-2019 1110 Fleming 3 $420,000 $766 $445,000 548 Condo 1/1 199
05-22-2019 320 Mickens $575,000 $977 $589,000 588 Single Family 2/1 216
05-20-2019 317 Angela $1,732,000 $660 $1,925,000 2,622 Single Family 5/5 151
05-15-2019 623 Elizabeth $730,000 $1,102 $749,500 662 Single Family 1/1 44
05-02-2019 1112 Stickney $420,000 $820 $439,000 512 Townhouse 1/1 238
05-01-2019 155 Simonton 403 $1,775,000 $698 $1,775,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 693
05-01-2019 151 Simonton 401 $1,800,000 $708 $1,925,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 87
05-01-2019 121 Simonton $1,825,000 $718 $1,950,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 219
04-30-2019 1007 Whitehead $513,500 $1,267 $549,000 405 Single Family 1/1 105
04-30-2019 614 Grinnell $1,575,000 $1,060 $1,575,000 1,485 Single Family 2/2 61
04-19-2019 326 Virginia $825,000 $701 $890,000 1,176 Single Family 3/3 369
04-12-2019 605 Margaret $565,000 $615 $575,000 918 Single Family 2/2 128
04-12-2019 620 Ashe $1,900,000 $995 $1,949,000 1,908 Single Family 3/3 143
04-10-2019 213 Truman A $400,000 $826 $419,000 484 Single Family 1/1 73
04-10-2019 906 Frances B $615,000 $734 $610,000 837 Townhouse 2/2 15
04-10-2019 626 Caroline $650,000 $601 $655,000 1,080 Single Family 2/2 147
04-03-2019 315 Amelia $875,000 $684 $899,000 1,278 Single Family 3/2 142
03-20-2019 11 Nassau $749,000 $990 $749,000 756 Single Family 2/2 104
03-08-2019 101 Admirals $5,870,000 $1,849 $5,980,000 3,173 Single Family 5/4 633
02-28-2019 533 Petronia $700,000 $462 $799,999 1,512 Single Family 3/2 219
02-28-2019 525 OLIVIA ST $925,000 $514 $995,000 1,798 Single Family 3/2 84
02-28-2019 522 Emma $3,300,000 $1,098 $3,562,500 3,004 Single Family 5/3 630
02-26-2019 123 Simonton $1,825,000 $718 $1,950,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 15
02-26-2019 119 Simonton $2,100,000 $826 $2,100,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 1
02-05-2019 719 Fleming $3,000,000 $1,192 $3,295,000 2,516 Single Family 4/3 79
02-04-2019 728 Ashe $605,000 $427 $599,000 1,416 Single Family 2/2 52
01-31-2019 1019 Whitehead $1,000,000 $728 $1,049,000 1,373 Single Family 3/2 213
01-31-2019 813 Frances $1,185,000 $817 $1,199,000 1,450 Single Family 2/2 87
01-30-2019 224 Olivia $425,000 $613 $450,000 693 Single Family 2/1 148
01-24-2019 630 Dey $3,600,000 $956 $3,700,000 3,763 Single Family 5/7 157
01-18-2019 716 Duval $2,150,000 $1,739 $2,178,000 1,236 Single Family 3/2 36
01-09-2019 624 Mickens $400,000 $421 $525,000 948 Single Family 2/1 611
01-07-2019 629 Elizabeth $1,275,000 $774 $1,300,000 1,647 Single Family 3/3 60
01-04-2019 925 Fleming $2,400,000 $1,044 $2,650,000 2,298 Single Family 3/2 65
01-03-2019 125 Simonton $2,200,000 $865 $2,299,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 511
01-02-2019 1026 Whitehead $475,000 $516 $550,000 920 Single Family 2/2 90
12-28-2018 608 Grinnell $605,000 $367 $499,000 1,648 Single Family 2/1 92
11-30-2018 908 Fleming $5,000,000 $1,953 $5,900,000 2,560 Single Family 4/4 1
11-29-2018 809 Virginia $950,000 $844 $979,000 1,125 Single Family 2/2 86
11-15-2018 717 Fort $475,000 $659 $499,000 720 Duplex 2/2 247
11-15-2018 518 Emma $2,175,000 $1,257 $2,395,000 1,730 Single Family 4/2 276
11-13-2018 1123 Whitehead $550,000 $761 $595,000 722 Duplex 2/2 42
11-09-2018 520 William $1,210,000 $871 $1,273,000 1,388 Single Family 3/2 280
10-31-2018 626 William $3,400,000 $961 $3,750,000 3,536 Single Family 6/4 328
10-19-2018 813 Shavers $758,753 $451 $794,900 1,680 Single Family 3/2 140
10-17-2018 611 William $1,400,000 $448 $1,499,000 3,120 Multi-Units 5/5 686
10-16-2018 306 Amelia $490,000 $418 $490,000 1,172 Single Family 4/2 191
09-28-2018 403-405 Caroline $1,600,000 $595 $1,695,000 2,688 Multi-Units 4/3 102
09-06-2018 321 Margaret $543,000 $754 $575,000 720 Single Family 2/2 191
09-04-2018 704 William $1,300,000 $785 $1,399,000 1,654 Single Family 3/4 294
09-04-2018 316 Admirals $3,250,000 $1,496 $3,450,000 2,172 Single Family 4/4 292
08-31-2018 307 Catherine $475,000 $465 $475,000 1,020 Single Family 2/1 145
08-30-2018 514 Elizabeth $1,300,000 $768 $1,350,000 1,692 Single Family 3/2 199
08-30-2018 153 Simonton 402 $1,700,000 $676 $1,755,000 2,514 Townhouse 3/3 12
08-30-2018 157 Simonton 404 $1,900,000 $747 $1,950,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 456
08-28-2018 318 Admirals $2,500,000 $1,274 $2,675,000 1,962 Single Family 3/3 124
08-24-2018 409 Margaret 202 / B $399,000 $620 $424,000 643 Condo 2/1 165
08-08-2018 127 Simonton 101 $1,799,000 $707 $1,799,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 8
08-08-2018 135 Simonton 105 $1,825,000 $718 $1,849,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 1270
08-06-2018 620 Frances $1,825,000 $907 $1,900,000 2,012 Single Family 4/3 52
08-02-2018 320 Mickens $575,000 $977 $599,000 588 Single Family 2/1 81
07-27-2018 1012 Fleming $1,435,000 $647 $1,675,000 2,215 Multi-Units 6/5 155
07-27-2018 923 Fleming $1,450,000 $520 $1,575,000 2,788 Multi-Units 5/4 289
07-27-2018 133 Simonton 104 $1,725,000 $678 $1,775,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 1258
07-23-2018 802 Southard $1,100,000 $389 $1,150,000 2,827 Multi-Units 6/4 50
07-20-2018 508 Emma $1,599,000 $876 $1,795,000 1,825 Townhouse 4/3 219
07-19-2018 1116 Whitehead $565,000 $784 $594,000 720 Single Family 2/2 228
07-17-2018 1124 Eaton $715,000 $555 $774,000 1,288 Single Family 2/2 277
07-11-2018 1113 Curry $1,500,000 $904 $1,649,000 1,658 Single Family 3/3 72
07-11-2018 615 Southard $1,575,000 $917 $1,699,000 1,717 Single Family 3/3 129
07-06-2018 711 Olivia $699,900 $560 $699,900 1,248 Single Family 3/1 30
06-29-2018 713 Eaton $1,100,000 $820 $1,300,000 1,340 Single Family 3/2 128
06-29-2018 617 Southard $1,499,000 $806 $1,499,000 1,859 Single Family 3/2 8
06-25-2018 1108 Olivia $585,000 $664 $619,000 880 Duplex 3/2 160
06-21-2018 1016 Howe 5 $277,000 $1,923 $299,900 144 Condo /1 70
06-14-2018 129 Simonton 102 $1,725,000 $678 $1,775,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 1215
06-14-2018 1011 Eaton $1,900,000 $873 $1,950,000 2,176 Single Family 3/3 121
06-05-2018 506 Emma $1,495,000 $929 $1,549,000 1,608 Townhouse 3/3 51
06-01-2018 131 Simonton 103 $1,800,000 $708 $1,825,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 1202
05-31-2018 812 Windsor $1,500,000 $642 $1,775,000 2,334 Single Family 4/4 133
05-25-2018 1100 Southard $1,240,000 $558 $1,550,000 2,220 Single Family 2/1 95
05-25-2018 322 Elizabeth $2,100,000 $858 $2,295,000 2,446 Single Family 4/2 123
05-15-2018 1120 Duval $777,500 $959 $799,000 810 Single Family 2/1 28
05-01-2018 819 Elizabeth $921,050 $898 $989,000 1,025 Single Family 2/1 162
04-26-2018 627 Caroline $1,160,000 $520 $1,395,000 2,230 Single Family 3/2 28
04-18-2018 910 Simonton 2 $470,000 $1,587 $469,000 296 Condo 1/1 148
04-10-2018 112 Hutchinson $1,083,777 $942 $1,150,000 1,150 Single Family 2/1 21
04-06-2018 618 Catholic $1,234,000 $1,038 $1,295,000 1,188 Single Family 2/2 280
04-04-2018 612 Mickens $555,000 $689 $650,000 805 Single Family 3/1 126
04-02-2018 308 Julia $499,000 $627 $525,000 795 Single Family 2/1 83
04-02-2018 623 Southard $2,100,000 $932 $2,200,000 2,252 Single Family 4/4 43
04-02-2018 1020 Southard $2,400,000 $873 $2,495,000 2,748 Single Family 4/4 153
03-30-2018 714 Chapman $915,000 $953 $995,000 960 Single Family 2/2 179
03-26-2018 628 Margaret $620,000 $861 $699,000 720 Single Family 2/2 7
03-23-2018 923 Angela $965,000 $968 $980,000 996 Single Family 2/2 242
03-20-2018 508 Grinnell $1,850,000 $902 $1,899,000 2,049 Single Family 3/3 43
03-16-2018 628 Margaret $485,000 $668 $399,000 726 Single Family 1/1 40
03-16-2018 1126 Stump $520,000 $912 $534,900 570 Single Family 1/1 205
03-12-2018 413 Frances $1,250,000 $813 $1,299,000 1,536 Single Family 3/3 154
03-12-2018 147 Simonton 302 $1,725,000 $678 $1,775,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 418
03-12-2018 139 Simonton 202 $1,800,000 $708 $1,850,000 2,541 Townhouse 3/3 432
03-05-2018 408 Amelia $859,350 $708 $869,000 1,213 Single Family 3/2 46
03-02-2018 1025 Eaton $1,065,000 $794 $1,095,000 1,340 Single Family 2/2 81
02-28-2018 1006 Fleming $3,100,000 $910 $3,595,000 3,404 Single Family 4/4 129
Thinking about selling your Old Town - Unrecord home?

Get a free no obligation home value report and know your home's value, even if you are just curious. If you decide to sell or are considering it, our company specializes in selling homes in your community and we can provide you with the guidance on the process that will generate the most return on your investment. Inquire below for a free comparative market analysis of your property. All communication is private and no obligation.

Provide us with some quick details so we can setup a free no obligation and confidential phone call.


The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 02-17-2020.

Broker's Edge Realty
92300 Overseas Hwy Suite 303
Key Largo, Florida 33070

1(800) 692-3605
Contact Us