Big Pine Key Real Estate for Sale, Homes and Condos in the Florida Keys

The Big Pine Key real estate market, located in the Lower Keys, is one of the most popular in the Florida Keys.  Not only is it one of the most beautiful and natural islands in the chain, with popular attractions like Bahia State Park, but it is also one of the largest geographically.  Big Pine Key homes and condominiums can be found at all pricepoints to suit all buyers.  Because of its size, it is also a popular place to purchase vacant land or ROGO lots.  Browse all real estate listings in Big Pine Key.

Popular Searches for Big Pine Key, FL

These are the most popular Big Pine Key real estate searches. The categories below can help you simplify your searches by accessing the listings you are looking for with quick links, for more specific Big Pine Key MLS searches please use our advanced search to help you pin point the the exact property you are looking for.

Currently as of today October 14, 2019 there are 55 homes for sale in Big Pine Key, 43 of those houses are waterfront MLS listings. Big Pine Key also has 0 condos for sale and 0 of those condo listings are waterfront properties for sale. These Realtor listings are in 23 different neighborhoods in this Florida Keys city. This changes daily so be sure to sign up for email alerts, or contact a Big Pine Key Realtor from our team of experts.


23 Communities in Big Pine Key, Florida

Avg Price # For Sale Neighborhood Mile Marker Min Price Max Price
$602,499 2 Atlantis Estates MM 31.00 $579,999 $625,000
$1,899,000 1 Big Pine Key Inc MM 31.00 $1,899,000 $1,899,000
$474,499 2 Cahill Pines & Palms MM 30.00 $389,000 $559,999
$390,000 1 Cook Island MM 29.00 $390,000 $390,000
$539,700 5 Doctors Arm MM 30.50 $432,000 $729,000
$938,666 6 Eden Pines Colony MM 29.00 $449,000 $2,750,000
$612,000 2 Hollerich Subdivision MM 31.00 $599,000 $625,000
$1,249,000 1 J R Matthews Properties MM 30.50 $1,249,000 $1,249,000
$355,000 1 Koehns Subdivision MM 30.50 $355,000 $355,000
$339,000 1 Linda Loma Subdivision MM 30.00 $339,000 $339,000
$1,049,000 3 Long Beach Estates MM 33.00 $799,000 $1,399,000
$470,000 2 Misc Big Pine Key MM 30.00 $375,000 $565,000
$289,500 2 Palm Villa MM 30.50 $250,000 $329,000
$639,000 2 Pine Channel Estates MM 29.50 $629,000 $649,000
$429,000 1 Pine Key Acres MM 30.50 $429,000 $429,000
$375,000 1 Pine Ridge MM 30.50 $375,000 $375,000
$1,299,900 1 Piney Point Subdivision MM 29.50 $1,299,900 $1,299,900
$485,833 9 Port Pine Heights MM 29.00 $380,000 $649,000
$549,000 1 Punta Brisa MM 31.00 $549,000 $549,000
$271,333 6 Sands Subdivision MM 31.00 $151,000 $390,000
$727,998 6 Tropical Bay MM 30.50 $559,990 $1,399,000
$356,000 1 Tropical Key Colony MM 30.00 $356,000 $356,000
$649,966 3 Whispering Pines MM 30.50 $549,900 $799,999
Big Pine Key, Florida

Current Big Pine Key Market Statistics as of 10-14-2019

Total Listings Type Lowest Price Highest Price Avg Price
55 All Homes $250,000 $2,750,000 $639,868
43 Homes - Waterfront $375,000 $2,750,000 $712,274
0 All Condos $0 $0 $0
0 Condos - Waterfront $0 $0 $0

About Big Pine Key

Big Pine Key is located in the Lower Florida Keys.  Its land size of approximately 10 square miles makes it the largest of the Lower Keys, and second in all the Keys only to Key Largo.  Its natural beauty and wide variety of real estate types have made Big Pine Key one of the most popular Keys on which to live.

Historically, Big Pine Key was once the home to several Native American tribes.  Evidence of these early tribes can be seen  in the many archaeological artifacts that have been found throughout the island.  Archaeologists have found fragments of ancient pottery, weapons, animal bones, and worked shells in several spots in Big Pine Key.  Since these days, Big Pine Key has maintained its natural roots, while growing into a haven for real estate.

The area around Big Pine Key is a quiet, peaceful expanse of land.  In fact, between Marathon and Key West the land is very natural and untouched.  This stretch of land has no fast food restaurants, malls, or other commercialization.  Big Pine Key is an island devoted to the island life of sun, sand, and sparkling water.  Real estate in Big Pine Key mirrors this notion, with the vast majority of homes being waterfront and secluded.  Homes for sale in Big Pine Key range from affordable single family homes, to waterfront townhomes, to multimillion dollar estates.  Some of the most luxurious neighborhoods in Big Pine Key include Long Beach Estates, Eden Pines Colony, and Whispering Pines.

Whatever their size and price tag, though, Big Pine Key real estate allows residents to take advantage of the beauty and solitude of the Lower Florida Keys.  One of the major draws to the area is Bahia Honda State Park.  This beautiful natural wonder includes a variety of indigenous plants and animals.  The park also includes a private beach, marina, RV park, and camping areas.  Big Pine Key is also very well-known as being the home to the endangered Key Deer, which can be seen throughout the island.

Big Pine Key real estate in the Florida Keys offers a private retreat in beautiful surroundings, and is perfect for those looking for any type of housing.

Shoreline Properties
92300 Overseas Hwy Suite 303
Key Largo, Florida 33070

1(800) 692-3605
Contact Us