Sugarloaf Key Homes for Sale, Single Family Houses, MLS Home Listings

Looking for single family houses for sale in Sugarloaf Key?  This area in the Lower Florida Keys is nestled in one of the most beautiful natural enclaves in the Keys, with Sugarloaf Key properties affording stunning views of tropical foliage, distinctive mangroves, and sparkling open water.  The location of Sugarloaf Key homes beautifully combines a secluded atmosphere with easy access to popular destinations, only 20 minutes from lively Key West.  Browse the Florida Keys MLS to see all real estate listings of homes for sale in Sugarloaf Key.

Total Listings 35
 1 2 > 
 

$145,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 19
  • MLS ID 119102
    Sq Ft: 1,200
  • Community: Indian Mound Estates Days on Market: 274
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Median Dockage: None

Bank approved price. Elevated modular home in great neighborhood, Indian Mounds - Sugarloaf Key. Three bedrooms and two baths upstairs and dry storage enclosure downstairs. Spacious, fenced lot. Loads of potential. Home currently does not have a kitchen, a/c or hot water heater. This is a short sale transaction and Buyer will be responsible for 1.5% of purchase price negotiator fee and a non-refundable $550 fee for filing with the sellers attorney for permission to sell the house due to chapter 13.

$269,900 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 1
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 564790
    Sq Ft: 996
  • Community: Sugarloaf Subdivision Days on Market: 80
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: None

Great starter home in Sugarloaf Key, Close to Sugarloaf Elementary and Middle School. Fenced yard with 2 door garage. Floors in hallway and bedrooms are waiting for your personal touch.To submit an offer on the property for consideration, click on the following link to submit through RES.NET: RES.NET Property Offer

$315,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 2 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 19
  • MLS ID 119805
    Sq Ft: 1,080
  • Community: Indian Mound Estates Days on Market: 143
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

A nice 2 bedroom 2 bath stilt house in the Indian Mounds Estates subdivision. Conveniently located in a nice neighborhood near schools, hiking trails, and boating access to all the wonders of our Florida Keys. Only 20 minutes to Key West yet miles away from all the hub bub.

$349,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 116572
    Sq Ft: 1,476
  • Community: Sugarloaf Acres Days on Market: 850
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

A unique property with potential to be your very own private oasis yet only minutes from Key West. This property features 3 separate parcels totally 3 acres and is completely fenced in with several mature trees and palms. There is a one story house and an unattached workshop/bldg nearby. Sugarloaf Schools are within walking distance.

$349,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 120041
    Sq Ft: 1,200
  • Community: Orchid Park Subdivision Days on Market: 92
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: None

One of the lowest priced canal front homes on Sugarloaf. 3/2 split floor plan, new appliances, tile in main areas, new carpet in bedrooms, freshly painted, walk-in closet, laundry room, fenced yard, ground level storage, covered entry, covered screen porch, sundeck and protected sunset views.

$355,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 19
  • MLS ID 119420
    Sq Ft: 1,500
  • Community: Misc Baypoint/sugarl Days on Market: 219
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

In the last six years, this elevated spacious 3/2 home on dry lot has been completely remodeled inside w./new windows,central a/c, Energy Star appliances,kitchen cabinets w./ granite countertops, lighting, fans, landscaping, doors & fresh paint & tiles, & rated hurricane shutters. Larger bedrooms, with an enormous fenced backyard and plenty of offstreet parking. Motivated Sellers will offer cash buyers substantial discount.

$449,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 565337
    Sq Ft: 1,248
  • Community: Orchid Park Subdivision Days on Market: 8
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage:

Beautiful canal-front home in peaceful, Orchid Park. Well built with loads of upgrades inside and out. HardiePlank siding, metal roof, pavers, composite decks, and newer railings. Large, diagonal tile throughout. Gorgeous kitchen with granite countertops, stainless appliances and solid wood cabinets. Large master bath with garden tub. Great access to fishing and boating hotspots!

$449,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 3
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 565015
    Sq Ft: 1,934
  • Community: Sugarloaf Acres Days on Market: 48
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

Enjoy peace and privacy at this secluded 1-Acre home with separate 1 BR Guest House on Sugarloaf Key. Ready for you to move in with a newly remodeled granite kitchen, large Master Suite with built-in cabinetry, and spacious Great Room with beautiful wood-beamed ceilings. Plenty of room to entertain and play w/large screened in pool & barn for all of your toys.

$499,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 562882
    Sq Ft: 1,344
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 289
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: None

Brand New Construction! This home is on the final stages of being completed! The home boasts 3 bedrooms 2 baths with open floor plan and when completed will have a deck off the kitchen/dining room, separate utility room, storage under the home and offers a 16,000 square foot lot! Photos of inside once construction is close to completion. Floor plan in photos.

$529,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 2 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 120012
    Sq Ft: 984
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 98
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Davits,Other Dockage

Desirable Sugarloaf Shores neighborhood with some of the best canals in the Florida Keys! 2 bedroom, 2 bath plus den canal front home with beautiful tropical landscaping! Dock with electric davits and floating dock for kayaks. Plenty of room for a pool on this oversized corner lot. Screened porch overlooking canal, covered parking for two cars and storage area under the house. Den could easily be a third bedroom.

$539,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 120047
    Sq Ft: 1,200
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 88
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage:

Desirable Sugarloaf Shores neighborhood with large lots and wide, deep clear canals! This 3 bedroom, two bath CBS stilt home has a concrete step down dock and great boating to the ocean or back country. Low maintenance yard and downstairs enclosure and covered parking for two vehicles.

$549,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 3
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 118900
    Sq Ft: 1,902
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 312
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Davit Pads,Davits Other

One of the first houses built in Sugarloaf Shores, this sprawling house offers privacy on an oversized, beautifully landscaped lot. Swim in a large pool surrounded by a courtyard and tropical trees. Back gate opens onto a private dock with davits on wide canal just minutes from the back country and ocean. 3 bedrooms and 3 baths, living and dining room, kitchen with adjoining room and attached 2 car garage complete the picture.

$550,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 564685
    Sq Ft: 1,320
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 93
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Davits 100ft. Concrete

PALM TREE PARADISE - numerous coconut palms and the wide, clear canal remind us that life is good in the Keys. This CBS home is situated on a 100x125 ft. fenced lot with 100 ft. canal-frontage, concrete seawall and a covered wood dock. 3bd/2ba with tile floors throughout. Hip roof, convenient walk-around porch. The huge back yard offers room for a pool and more. Just 17 miles from Key West.

$599,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 2 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 564242
    Sq Ft: 1,250
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 148
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage:

Located on a wide canal with open water views from the dock. Private 15,000 sq. ft. lot with mature landscaping make this tropical retreat an entertaining showcase. Two screened porches and beautiful gardens enhance this home. Downstairs enclosure, hot tub, fenced yard, newer metal roof are just a few of the amenities this property has to offer.

$675,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 559411
    Sq Ft: 1,610
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 692
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage:

Tropical Waterfront Pool home in Sugarloaf Shores. This CBS home was custom built in 2000 & sprawls over a 15,500 SF lushly landscaped yard for complete privacy. 1,610 SF w/open floor plan & very spacious rooms. Tiled throughout, crown moldings, French doors, front & back porches. Dock with easy ocean & gulf access. Heated pool surrounded by colorful gardens. 2-Car over-sized garage & metal roof.

$693,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 119734
    Sq Ft: 2,190
  • Community: Hildas Subdivision Days on Market: 161
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Bay Front
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

This one of a kind secluded property sits on 4.5 Pristine acres bordering the Florida Keys National Wildlife refuge. The 2190 Sq. Ft. residence features an open floor plan, wrap around porch, outdoor dining area, spacious and updated kitchen, hardwood floors, three bedrooms, two-and-a-half bathrooms, and breathtaking views. Outside, you will find a private outdoor shower, garden, natural trails, a pond, and a large circular driveway. This is a must see property. Schedule a showing today to come and explore this piece of paradise yourself.

$750,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 119770
    Sq Ft: 1,670
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 149
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Median Dockage: Boat Lift

Motivated Seller! Bring all offers! Rock solid 3/2 located on a clean & deep swimming/boating canal.Low maintenance is the charm of this home with features including a metal roof, tile floors, PGT Hurricane rated storm windows and a 16,000 lb capacity boat elevator all designed to make your life easier. Inside the home is a lovely chef friendly kitchen and a living/dining space with doors opening onto the deck which has a staircase leading down to the canal and large storage closet. 2 bedrooms and 1 bath are on the first floor,the second story is all master-suite with its own private porch and very large closet. The 12,500sf lot is fenced and gated with low maintenance landscaping. This property has much to offer. Put it on your list.

$799,900 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 118867
    Sq Ft: 2,116
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 316
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Davit Pads,Davits

Your perfect private getaway or permanent home is located on a beautiful wide open swimming canal just minutes from ocean and back country. With a extra large lot, docks, and davits, it is has everything for the boater, fisherman or diver. On top of everything is a Chickee Hut next to a beautiful pool which is just outside-no walking down stairs. Home has 3 bedrooms, granite counter tops and stainless appliances. The quiet desirable neighborhood in Sugarloaf Shores is just minutes from the Key West.

$849,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 4 Baths: 3
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 119241
    Sq Ft: 3,024
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 251
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Davits Other

Waterfront Pool Home 4 bedroom over in Sugarloaf Shores! Waterfront with full concrete dock, davits, private boat ramp, & quick open water access. 3,024 SF home with a pool, great for entertaining. Large lot room for your toys. Lots of storage & large yard for pets & children.

$849,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 0
  • MLS ID 119197
    Sq Ft: 2,300
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 259
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Other

NO STAIRS! Beautifully appointed Keys home on double lot in exclusive Sugarloaf Shores. CBS ground level that has never flood in main home! Updated kitchen with SS appliances and granite counters, new windows, new baths, cedar walk in closets, and easy close shutters. Tax roll says 3 bedroom when there are 2 but room for at least 2 more. Beautiful working fireplace for some chilly nights. Huge landscaped yard for entertaining. Seawall. Quick access to the gulf or ocean. Salt water aquarium type pool in rear. A real keysy home. Can come furnished.

 1 2 > 
The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 10-02-2014.