Divider
Content Divider

Sugarloaf Key Homes for Sale, Single Family Houses, MLS Home Listings

Looking for single family houses for sale in Sugarloaf Key?  This area in the Lower Florida Keys is nestled in one of the most beautiful natural enclaves in the Keys, with Sugarloaf Key properties affording stunning views of tropical foliage, distinctive mangroves, and sparkling open water.  The location of Sugarloaf Key homes beautifully combines a secluded atmosphere with easy access to popular destinations, only 20 minutes from lively Key West.  Browse the Florida Keys MLS to see all real estate listings of homes for sale in Sugarloaf Key.

Total Listings 34
Order By:

19580  Mayan Street  For Sale, MLS 585237
$430,000
Sugarloaf Key
Indian Mound Estates   - MM: 19.50
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,213 SqFt Days Listed: 416
-3.37% ($15,000) 3 Price Changes : Last Change 119 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Beautiful renovated 3/2 conch home in Indian Mound! Several years ago this home was renovated to include new appliances, new metal roof, central ac, impact rated front, and rear doors, sky blue painted wood floors, new cabinetry, and more. There are beautiful blues and greens throughout this home, large covered front porch, back deck, and large master bath. Wonderful large covered porch in the front of the house, and a wooden deck in the back. The public boat ramp is right around the corner!

19525  Mayan Street  For Sale, MLS 589806
$475,000
Sugarloaf Key
Indian Mound Estates   - MM: 19.50
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,587 SqFt Days Listed: 112
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: None

Spacious custom built home with mature landscaping! Open floor plan with cathedral ceilings, three bedrooms and two baths with custom exotic wood work and beautiful staircase to upper level master suite with en suite bath, hardwood floors, cedar lined closets, and area for office space or use your imagination! Tile floors on main level with custom kitchen with beautiful cabinets, center island, and pantry! Downstairs storage area, covered parking, and mature landscaping! Mature landscaping with 2500 gal. cistern. Private neighborhood boat ramp, BBQ and picnic area! Adjacent lot next door not listed but is available as a package deal for the right price!

19442  Canal Drive  For Sale, MLS 589706
$505,000
Sugarloaf Key
Perez Subdivision   - MM: 19.50
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,676 SqFt Days Listed: 115
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: None

Sunny Days- Enjoy your sunny days in this 3/2 home on Upper Sugarloaf Key. Recent updates throughout. Home boasts two master suites, one downstairs and one upstairs. A welcoming and inviting porch off the living area and another large porch off the upstairs master. Lots of storage including a separate storage shed, a bonus room off the porch and a large laundry room. One of the owners is a licensed Real Estate Broker.

17346  Jamaica Lane  For Sale, MLS 591067
$525,000
Sugarloaf Key
Orchid Park Subdivision   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,092 SqFt Days Listed: 4
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: n/a

Move in ready and affordable insurance makes this 3 bedroom 2 bath, elevated, waterfront home in beautiful Sugarloaf Key, the perfect home for you. This house now has a new metal roof, new hot water heater, new carpeting in bedrooms, all new ceiling fans and light fixtures, fresh paint and a brand new washer and dryer. A floating wooden 12 dock is already in place and a downstairs storage enclosure ready to store your kayaks, paddle boards and other essentials.

17232  Snapper Lane  For Sale, MLS 590932
$544,500
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,344 SqFt Days Listed: 17
-0.07% ($400) 1 Price Change : Last Change 14 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: None

2014 Modular Home with Hardi Board and impact windows in Sugarloaf Shores. This home sits on a 8400sqft waterfront lot with 3 Bedroom 2 Bath an open floor plan with stainless steel appliances that is move in ready.

19573 -19581 Mayan Street  For Sale, MLS 587956
$549,000
Sugarloaf Key
Indian Mound Estates   - MM: 19.50
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 960 SqFt Days Listed: 219
-1.79% ($10,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 124 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: None

Amazing opportunity in the hottest neighborhood close to Key West! Property consists of a single family home on a 5,000 square foot lot plus a vacant 50 x 100 developable lot. Two RE#s. Nestled in the trees among lush tropical landscaping you will find your Zen moment. There is a feeling of being in Bali with lots of exposed wood and a wrap around deck in the treetops. The screened in porch is magical and gives the home an inside outside feeling to be enjoyed all year long. This colorful home designed by a well known local architect has an open floor plan with lots of windows and doors opening to the porches to appreciate your private hideaway. New roof in 2018! The adjacent 5,000 sq. ft. lot provides so many options...put in a pool, store your toys or build a new home to sell!

17233 E Starfish Lane  For Sale, MLS 590876
$580,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,236 SqFt Days Listed: 22
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: n/a

Canal front with gorgeous open water views! This home is in a great location with a short drive to Key West!!! Renovated 2 bedroom 1 bathroom home with a brand new roof, impact doors and windows, open kitchen with stainless appliances, quartz counter tops, laminate wood floors, brand new deck, fish cleaning station and outdoor shower. Large 8,125 sq ft lot with covered parking. Call us today for a showing!

91  Frazier Lane  For Sale, MLS 589425
$595,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Subdivision   - MM: 19.50
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,544 SqFt Days Listed: 130
+2.76% ($16,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 127 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront No
Side of Island: Median - Dockage: None

Private and quiet. VERY nice, updated single-family home at mile-marker 20. Two bedrooms on ground floor, huge master bedroom, bath and balcony on 2nd floor. Quartz countertops, rosewood flooring upstairs, security system. 17,500 sqft lot, fenced and landscaped. Architectural plans available for new addition. 2nd ROGO possible for dividing lot and constructing another home. Convenient Lower Keys location, between Key West and Big Pine. Youll be surprised! Close any time with allowance for sellers to rent-back until mid-June.

17213 E Starfish Lane  For Sale, MLS 588268
$649,900
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,750 SqFt Days Listed: 200
-12.16% ($90,000) 3 Price Changes : Last Change 11 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: Davits

70K price reduction! Seller wants it sold. Priced well below market, great location only a short drive to Key West. This CBS home built in 2000 sits on a 15,978 sq ft lot surrounded by a concrete privacy wall with gated drive. This bank owned 3/2 is waiting for you to make it your own estate. Lower level boasts a 1408 sq ft garage with 3 large doors. upstairs has a large master suite, granite tops and a nice view of the bay from your living area and master suite.

     For Sale, MLS 590415
$689,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,636 SqFt Days Listed: 70
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: Boat Ramp,Davits

This beautiful Cedar home features 3 Bedrooms, 2 full baths split floor plan, cathedral ceilings., great kitchen all wood cabinets, granite counter tops & nice appliances . Fully enclosed (windowed) porch. Two central air systems. Located in Beautiful Surgarloaf Shores with palm tree lined walking/bike paths. No road noise on Oleander Lane. New metal roof just one year old. Lots of storage 3 walk-in closets and large garage/workshop downstairs. Lots of room down to entertain & carport parking. 100 feet of waterfront, dock, davits & boat ramp. Room to park RV. Tropical landscaping . Key West is about a 15 to 20 minute drive.

17151  Marlin Drive  For Sale, MLS 588152
$695,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,522 SqFt Days Listed: 209
-18.14% ($154,000) 5 Price Changes : Last Change 79 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: n/a

PRICED $50K BELOW APPRAISED VALUE. SUGAR SHACK is located in one of the coolest boating neighborhoods near Key West. Here, your pristine free flowing canal serves as yourmaintenance free swimming pool. This elevated two story custom home sits on a lush, spacious lot affording many options: a boat ramp, RV, plus all your toys. 3 bed/2 bath property features an open concept plan with vaulted ceilings and french doors opening to breezy decks on both levels, plus an expansive wooden dock. Enjoy stunning water views and spectacular sunsets over Sugarloaf Sound. New roof, new bamboo flooring, new electric panel. Ample storage in the garage; multiple vehicle parking of street. Comes fully furnished for immediate occupancy or rental. High definition LED TV , stereo

1107  Hawksbill Lane  For Sale, MLS 591077
$725,000
Sugarloaf Key
Vacation Harbor   - MM: 19.50
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,152 SqFt Days Listed: 4
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: Davits68ft.Concrete

Here it is...Your Getaway in Paradise! Meticulously maintained home - elevated 3 bedrooms + office with 2 full baths. Open water views on a deep boating canal with 68 feet of dockage. Just 5 minutes by boat to the Atlantic or 7 minutes to the backcountry sand bars. Living room and bedrooms face breathtaking open water views as does the huge screened in porch. Numerous updates and upgrades inside and out of this pristine home. Kitchen has GE profile and Bosch appliances with coveted gas cooking. Countertops are solid quartz. Floors are carbonized bamboo throughout. Concrete Block construction (CBS) affords everything you want for the rigors of waterfront living. If you are spending more time at home these days... where else would you rather be?

17139  Amberjack Lane  For Sale, MLS 590410
$729,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
2 Bed, 2 Baths, 1,300 SqFt Days Listed: 71
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: Boat Lift

This gorgeous 2BR/2BA spacious tropical waterfront paradise stilt home sits on an oversized lot in the exclusive neighborhood of Sugarloaf Shores. The floorplan boasts island character with an open living/dining/kitchen with bamboo floors & tropical style ceiling fans. Glass sliding doors open onto an enormous open deck, an entertainers dream for outdoor entertaining. Both BRs are large, master ensuite has a double vanity & shower. After a day on the water put your boat on the 15,000lb boat lift, sit back & relax sipping a sunset cocktail under your Tiki Hut, while you take in spectacular views thro the canal onto Sugarloaf Sound. Permitted 2 car garage/storage for all your fishing gear & water toys.Metal roof. 100FT concrete dock Crystal clear canal.20 mins to Key West & Intl airport

17126  Wahoo Lane  For Sale, MLS 589766
$735,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,152 SqFt Days Listed: 113
-4.42% ($34,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 10 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: Boat Ramp,Davits

Gorgeous views down the 80 wide crystal clear canal from this recently updated 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom home. Beautifully appointed Kitchen with Quartz countertops and farmhouse sink, spacious open floor plan with new tile flooring and large master bedroom with ensuite bath. Sit back and relax on the large wrap around deck or by the dockside fire pit. The 12,500 sq. ft. tropically landscaped lot offers plenty of room for your boats and toys with a full 125 concrete step down dock with boat ramp, davits and quick water access to world class fishing and diving. Located just 15 minutes to all the magic and amenities of Key West!

16880  Driftwood Lane  For Sale, MLS 590514
$784,900
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,344 SqFt Days Listed: 60
-1.76% ($14,100) 1 Price Change : Last Change 6 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: Davits

3/2 Waterfront Pool home located on an 80 wide crystal clear canal in Sugarloaf Shores! Days are enjoyed lounging by the waterfront pool boasting lots of decking or heading out on the water for a day of fishing & diving from the concrete dock equipped w/Davits. After a day on the water friends & family can gather in the large Kitchen complete w/Dining Island & Breakfast Nook or on the Porch to enjoy alfresco dining over the water. Picturesque views of the heated Pool & water are also enjoyed from the Master Suite w/newly remodeled granite Bath. The 2 Guest Rooms are adorned w/Plantation Shutters & share a newly remodeled Bathroom. Plenty of room for RV, trailer & toys on the large 12,232 sq. ft. lot. This home is storm ready w/new metal roof & hurricane impact doors & windows. Turn Key!

17217 E Dolphin Street  For Sale, MLS 589869
$899,900
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,652 SqFt Days Listed: 107
-9.92% ($99,100) 1 Price Change : Last Change 2 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: Boat Ramp

This custom built 3 BR 2 BA waterfront home with a working boat ramp sits on an oversized 15,100 sq. ft. lot where there is plenty of room for a pool and all of your toys including RV and trailer storage! Enter into the spacious Great Room which boasts soaring ceilings and an open Kitchen offering a large center island, granite counters and stainless appliances. Great outdoor spaces for entertaining including a large Porch overlooking the water and a covered Lanai. Excellent boating access from the dock and ramp plus quick ocean access through Tarpon Creek with no bridges. Hurricane ready with impact doors and windows, no need for shutters! Sugarloaf Shores is an upscale neighborhood which was featured in Islands Magazine as on of the Top 20 Islands worldwide to live on.

1261  Crane Boulevard  For Sale, MLS 591050
$950,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Acres   - MM: 19.50
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 2,440 SqFt Days Listed: 5
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: n/a

Elegant elevated 2-story home hidden on 3 acres at edge of the National Great White Heron Wildlife Refuge. Tucked between a Florida Keys hardwood hammock (1.39 acres) and mangrove wetlands (.50 acres w/dock permits&survey in progress) that stretch to the Gulf of Mexico. This is where you go to get away from it all. Wonderfully private and geographically protected. 4B/3.5B with 2440sf indoor living space and 1500+sf of porches , balconies, catwalks. Two-car garage enclosed with 1200sf of ground-level storage space. Working cistern and more. Grassy front lawn on 45,000sf buildable lot has room for pool.

17218 E Dolphin Street  For Sale, MLS 587172
$1,099,000
Sugarloaf Key
Sugarloaf Shores   - MM: 17.00
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,844 SqFt Days Listed: 279
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: n/a

Pretty long water views down the canal from this custom built 3 BR/3BA home on over a 1/3 of an acre in Sugarloaf Shores. As you enter into the 1,844 sq. ft. home the Sun Room/Foyer greets you leading to the Great Room which boasts hardwood floors & Dining Area that overlooks the water. The adjacent Kitchen features a large center island, tons of custom cabinetry & black stainless appliances. The 3 large Bedrooms are all ensuite including the colossal Master Bedroom with updated bath and access to the Porch w/walk-around deck. Really quick ocean access w/no bridges via Tarpon creek from your composite dock. Room for all of your toys in the oversized 4-car garage. Gardeners will love the fully fenced yard with a large orchid house and lots of lush tropical landscaping.

1023  Loggerhead Lane  For Sale, MLS 588457
$1,100,000
Sugarloaf Key
Vacation Harbor   - MM: 19.50
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,645 SqFt Days Listed: 187
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: 300ft.

Must see to experience all this one of a kind property has to offer! Secluded oasis on the Gulf of Mexico with 2+ acres, boat dock and breathtaking views. An entertainers backyard with a sunny pool and covered bar only add to the magic of this 3 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom home with loft and widows walk. Double lot with electric hook-up allows for RV on property. Pool and deck renovated in 2018. Exterior of house completely painted in 2018 as well. A short 20 minute drive to Key West, but a world away from the hustle and bustle... come overwhelm your senses in this Florida Keys dream house!

1163  Hawksbill Lane  For Sale, MLS 588668
$1,239,000
Sugarloaf Key
Vacation Harbor   - MM: 19.50
3 Bed, 3 Baths, 1,656 SqFt Days Listed: 175
-0.80% ($10,000) 1 Price Change : Last Change 81 Days Ago
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Bay/Gulf - Dockage: Boat Lift

Sportsmans Paradise! Located on the open water at the entrance to the GREAT WHITE HERON NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE. Fish, Scuba Snorkel, and Kayak all from your backyard. The 3 BR home sprawls over a double point lot offering protected canal dockage w/10K lb boat lift, kayak ramp & immediate Gulf & easy Ocean access. The Old Florida-style home offers 1,656 sq. ft. plus a large Porch boasting picture perfect open water views. Entertaining is a must in the true Chefs Kitchen w/ granite counters, SS appliances, gas stove & breakfast nook looking out to the water. The Master Suite is complete w/walk-in closet, spa Bath & endless water views. This home is storm ready w/ hurricane impact doors & windows, metal roof & whole house generator w/auto-switch & alarm system. ONE OF A KIND LOCATION!

The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 06-04-2020.

Broker's Edge Realty
92300 Overseas Hwy Suite 303
Key Largo, Florida 33070

1(800) 692-3605
Contact Us

Back To Top
Terms / Privacy / Accessibility ADA