Sugarloaf Key Homes for Sale, Single Family Houses, MLS Home Listings

Looking for single family houses for sale in Sugarloaf Key?  This area in the Lower Florida Keys is nestled in one of the most beautiful natural enclaves in the Keys, with Sugarloaf Key properties affording stunning views of tropical foliage, distinctive mangroves, and sparkling open water.  The location of Sugarloaf Key homes beautifully combines a secluded atmosphere with easy access to popular destinations, only 20 minutes from lively Key West.  Browse the Florida Keys MLS to see all real estate listings of homes for sale in Sugarloaf Key.

Total Listings 39
 1 2 > 
 

$299,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 120767
    Sq Ft: 1,476
  • Community: Sugarloaf Acres Days on Market: 109
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

A unique property with potential to be your very own private oasis yet only minutes from Key West. This property features 3 separate parcels totally 3 acres and is completely fenced in with several mature trees and palms. There is a one story house and an unattached workshop/bldg nearby. Sugarloaf Schools are within walking distance.

$310,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 121146
    Sq Ft: 1,152
  • Community: Indian Mound Estates Days on Market: 45
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

Elevated three bedroom, two bath home located within walking distance of Sugarloaf School and community center. This home features an enclosed storage area, high ceiling, an open floor plan, tile floors in the living area, a fenced back yard and a community boat ramp. A great starter home only 15 miles from Key West.

$339,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 19
  • MLS ID 121011
    Sq Ft: 1,173
  • Community: Indian Mound Estates Days on Market: 65
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

Brand new home with Tile floors, Granite countertops , stainless steel appliances, metal roof and Hurricane impact windows and doors. Owner is a Florida licensed real estate agent. To be completed end of February .

$342,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 1 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 566312
    Sq Ft: 960
  • Community: Gulf Shores Days on Market: 79
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage:

Private and gated home located on an oversized lot with paver driveway and walkways. 1 bedroom and two baths - which could easily be converted back to its original floor plan of two bedrooms.Chefs kitchen, cathedral tongue and groove wood ceilings and covered porch overlooking canal. This is a Fannie Mae HomePath property.

$389,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 120925
    Sq Ft: 1,152
  • Community: Vacation Harbor Days on Market: 76
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage:

A wonderful canal front, 3 bed, 2.5 bath home in a serene area of Sugarloaf. Enjoy the luxury of having a large master suite with a spa-style bathroom and French doors opening up to a view of the water. The other 2 bedrooms are a good size, one having its own half-bath. The spacious open living area incorporates the attractive well-appointed kitchen with its designer style wood and tile flooring. The many windows give the home a bright and cheerful feel. Outside is a large grassy front yard with flowering bushes, ideal for children and pets. There is plenty of storage with a shed and legal enclosure. At the rear of the home is a lovely waterside deck area on which to relax. The home is on a deep, wide canal with quick open water access.

$499,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 120479
    Sq Ft: 1,630
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 167
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: None

Tropical home in quiet neighborhood with in-ground pool on nicely landscaped lot. This 3/2 home has beautiful hardwood floors, new metal roof and new central air. All new appliances. Remodeled huge bathroom! 2 car garage and lots of storage. Minutes from Key West. Charming home in a lovely neighborhood.

$499,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 2 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 120012
    Sq Ft: 984
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 275
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Davits,Other Dockage

Easy To SEE!!! Desirable Sugarloaf Shores neighborhood with some of the best canals in the Florida Keys! 2 bedroom, 2 bath plus den canal front home with beautiful tropical landscaping! Dock with electric davits and floating dock for kayaks. Plenty of room for a pool on this oversized corner lot. Screened porch overlooking canal, covered parking for two cars and storage area under the house. Den could easily be a third bedroom.

$550,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 3
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 0
  • MLS ID 120229
    Sq Ft: 1,338
  • Community: Orchid Park Subdivision Days on Market: 225
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: None

Great opportunity!!! 15 minutes from Key West!!! Canal front house on a double lot with a lot of privacy. Plenty of space for entertaining. Parking for at least 4 cars. This house features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, ready to move in. If you are looking for Piece of Paradise dont look any more you just found it!

$579,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 566508
    Sq Ft: 1,540
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 60
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage:

Lots of space for all of your toys at this spacious 3 BR/2 BA home in Sugarloaf Shores. The 16,117 SF lot offers great boating access w/2 docks + ramp & a garage for small craft. As you enter into the custom built home you will be greeted by an open floor plan featuring soaring wood-beamed ceilings, wood floors, and kitchen w/center cooking island. The colossal Master Suite boasts a cedar-lined

$599,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 566133
    Sq Ft: 1,450
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 98
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Davits 125ft. Concrete

3 Bedroom waterfront pool home in Sugarloaf Shores! Located on a 60 wide crystal clear canal w/125 concrete dock & davits. Spacious homes offers a large eat-in kitchen w/breakfast bar, living room overlooking the pool & water & walk-around deck. Colossal back yard is ideal for entertaining w/tiki pavillion & sparkling pool w/lots of decking. Fenced yard, 2-car garage, tropical landscaping.

$599,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 2 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 120744
    Sq Ft: 1,428
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 112
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Other

Great Buy On South Point...Huge Canal Front Lot With Seawall And Boat Ramp. Concrete Construction With Recent Upgrades...Wood Floor, Delightful Kitchen With Bar...Open Living Room And 2 Very Seperate Bedrooms And Baths...Tv Den Or Possible Third Bedroom...Very Tropical Inside And Out...Front And Rear Covered Decks...Spaceous 2 Car Garage And Covered Ground Level Patio

$599,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 2 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 566765
    Sq Ft: 1,344
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 36
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Cut/Natural

No expense was spared in the complete remodel of this absolutely perfect waterfront home in beautiful Sugarloaf Shores. Tastefully designed and decorated, this home shows better than most homes that are twice the price. Impact resistant windows and doors, standing seam metal roof and Hardiplank siding make this a durable, yet beautiful home. Put this one on your list - you wont be disappointed

$659,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 120951
    Sq Ft: 2,250
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 75
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Basin Other

This waterfront home has been renovated , Travertine tile, New Metal roof ,A/C, and Stainless steel appliances. Not to mention over 15,000 sq. ft. Lot. Truly a Gem in paradise. Did I mention boating access as well? Current flood insurance $2200 for max coverage.

$693,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 119734
    Sq Ft: 2,190
  • Community: Hildas Subdivision Days on Market: 338
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Bay Front
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

This one of a kind secluded property sits on 4.5 Pristine acres bordering the Florida Keys National Wildlife refuge. The 2190 Sq. Ft. residence features an open floor plan, wrap around porch, outdoor dining area, spacious and updated kitchen, hardwood floors, three bedrooms, two-and-a-half bathrooms, and breathtaking views. Outside, you will find a private outdoor shower, garden, natural trails, a pond, and a large circular driveway. This is a must see property. Schedule a showing today to come and explore this piece of paradise yourself.

$695,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 2 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 0
  • MLS ID 121029
    Sq Ft: 1,120
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 62
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front,Open Water
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: Other

Live the Keys Dream from a stunning waterfront property with incredible Sunset views of Lower Sugarloaf Sound, in this 2 bdrm/2 bath home. This property is on open water plus a wide, clean canal, with dock and rip-rap sea wall. You can have deep water boat access to the Atlantic and the Gulf, catch lobsters and crabs from the canal, fish, engage in water sports - or just relax and catch some rays, or nap in a hammock under the shade. Enjoy lush, mature tropical foliage, including palms, mangoes, bananas, and other exotic plantings. This home is listed at Appraised Value, ready to move - bring offers! Principal is Licensed RE Agent.

$710,000 - Other (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 119770
    Sq Ft: 1,670
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 326
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Median Dockage: Boat Lift

Bring all offers! MOTIVATED SELLERS. Rock solid 3/2 located on a clean & deep swimming/boating canal.Low maintenance is the charm of this home with features including a metal roof, tile floors, PGT Hurricane rated storm windows and a 16,000 lb capacity boat elevator all designed to make your life easier. Inside the home is a lovely chef friendly kitchen and a living/dining space with doors opening onto the deck which has a staircase leading down to the canal and large storage closet. 2 bedrooms and 1 bath are on the first floor,the second story is all master-suite with its own private porch and very large closet. The 12,500sf lot is fenced and gated with low maintenance landscaping.

$725,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 565446
    Sq Ft: 1,588
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 173
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage: 411ft.

Beautiful canal front home in Sugarloaf Shores this immaculate home sits on a 19,650sq ft lot, concrete circular driveway, tiled downstairs patio, split floor plan 3 bedrooms 2 baths, large laundry room, tile flooring, upstairs patio overlooking canal, pristine condition.Plenty of room for pool.

$750,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 3
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 565821
    Sq Ft: 1,622
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 133
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Canal Front
  • Side of Island: Ocean Dockage:

Enjoy gorgeous sunrise views over Sugarloaf Sound from your custom built 3 BR 2 BA home in Sugarloaf Shores. Located on the east side of the island this home offers quick ocean access through Tarpon creek. The 2-story home offers over 1,600 SF & boasts picturesque open water views from all Living Areas, including the screened Porch, and the private 2nd Story Master Suite. Dock, storage, & more!

$799,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 5 Baths: 3
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 20
  • MLS ID 566117
    Sq Ft: 2,512
  • Community: Maggie & Mary Days on Market: 100
  • Waterfront: No
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage: None

Spacious & Almost Brand New 5 Bedroom 2 Story Home Located on over 2 Acres of Privacy With Sunset Views. Beautiful wild life and quick commute to Key West. Features split floor plan, 2 private master suites, tile floors, custom kitchen, impact windows, metal roof. Room for a pool & or additions. Rogo Exempt Lot next acre over available for sale too. Located near elementary and middle school.

$849,000 - Sugarloaf (Sugarloaf Key) , FL

  • Beds: 3 Baths: 2
    Type: Single Family Home - MM: 17
  • MLS ID 566850
    Sq Ft: 2,450
  • Community: Sugarloaf Shores Days on Market: 27
  • Waterfront: Yes - Waterview: Open Water
  • Side of Island: Bay/Gulf Dockage:

This is a beautiful water open water home that comes with 3 bedrooms with lots of built in cabinets and abundance of storage plus a bonus room that could be a 4 bedroom or home office It also has a protected boat basin and has a 700 sq Ft screen porch with water feature A chefs kitchen with center island and in ground spa also a garage and lots of privacy , come enjoy your keys dreams today

 1 2 > 
The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 03-28-2015.