Content Divider

Sugarloaf Key Real Estate for Sale, Homes and Condos in the Florida Keys

The Sugarloaf Key real estate market is one of the largest in the Florida Keys.  With a location quite near popular areas like Key West, those interested in the Lower Florida Keys flock to purchase Sugarloaf Key homes and condos.  A great proportion of properties include waterfront homes for sale in Sugarloaf Key, and these are some of the most highly sought after in the market.  Sugarloaf Key is one of the most desired areas in the Florida Keys, with a wealth of top neighborhoods and condo communities to choose from.  Browse all real estate for sale in Sugarloaf Key using our comprehensive set of Florida Keys MLS listings.

Popular Searches for Sugarloaf Key, FL

These are the most popular Sugarloaf Key real estate searches. The categories below can help you simplify your searches by accessing the listings you are looking for with quick links, for more specific Sugarloaf Key MLS searches please use our advanced search to help you pin point the the exact property you are looking for.

Currently as of today April 19, 2024 there are 28 homes for sale in Sugarloaf Key, 24 of those houses are waterfront MLS listings. Sugarloaf Key also has 0 condos for sale and 0 of those condo listings are waterfront properties for sale. These Realtor listings are in 8 different neighborhoods in this Florida Keys city. This changes daily so be sure to sign up for email alerts, or contact a Sugarloaf Key Realtor from our team of experts.

8 Communities in Sugarloaf Key, Florida

Avg Price # For Sale Neighborhood Mile Marker Min Price Max Price
$989,000 1 Gulf Shores MM 19.50 $989,000 $989,000
$1,551,333 3 Indian Mound Estates MM 19.50 $865,000 $2,199,000
$899,000 1 Orchid Park Subdivision MM 17.00 $899,000 $899,000
$779,999 1 Perez Subdivision MM 19.50 $779,999 $779,999
$5,049,000 2 Sugarloaf Beach MM 17.00 $2,599,000 $7,499,000
$2,121,876 17 Sugarloaf Shores MM 17.00 $1,099,000 $5,699,000
$1,676,500 2 Sugarloaf Subdivision MM 19.50 $854,000 $2,499,000
$999,999 1 Vacation Harbor MM 19.50 $999,999 $999,999
Sugarloaf Key, Florida

Current Sugarloaf Key Market Statistics as of 04-19-2024

Total Listings Type Lowest Price Highest Price Avg Price
28 All Homes $779,999 $7,499,000 $2,065,889
24 Homes - Waterfront $899,000 $7,499,000 $2,239,829
0 All Condos $0 $0 $0
0 Condos - Waterfront $0 $0 $0

About Sugarloaf Key

Sugarloaf Key is part of Lower Florida Keys real estate, and is one of the largest in this chain of islands.  Just 20 minutes from exciting Key West, Sugarloaf Key offers easy access to this entertainment and cultural capital.  However, its secluded feel leaves residents living amidst natural Florida, with sparkling views of the Florida Straits, the Atlantic Ocean, and the Gulf of Mexico, as well as views of expansive mangrove forests.  Its seclusion exudes peace and tranquility for its residents.

Homes for sale in Sugarloaf Key are located between Cudjoe Key and Park Key.  The shape of Sugarloaf Key as a giant loop often causes some to consider it two separate keys, Upper Sugarloaf Key and Lower Sugarloaf Key with Upper Sugarloaf Sound and Park Key separating the two.  The two portions of the island are unique from one another.  Upper Sugarloaf Key is larger in land area, but is not as densely populated.  This area includes a church, campground, restaurant, and school.  Lower Sugarloaf Key is much more densely populated than Upper Sugarloaf Key.  One of the largest neighborhoods on Sugarloaf Key is Sugarloaf Shores.  Homes for sale in Sugarloaf Shores range in price from affordable single family homes to multi-million dollar oceanfront estates.  Other popular neighborhoods include Sugarloaf Acres and Sugarloaf Beach.  These exclusive neighborhoods offer waterfront properties with resort-like amenities and views. 

There are also many luxury estates in Sugarloaf Key scattered throughout the area and all along the shoreline. Old State Road 4a has some of the largest estate properties, along with County Road 939 Sugarloaf Key.  These estates are massive mansions along the water.  Real estate in Sugarloaf Key includes private enclaves in secluded areas of the Key as well.

Sugarloaf Key real estate and homes for sale are private paradises in the Florida Keys real estate market.    Those lucky enough to own property here have some of the most beautiful homes in the Florida Keys.

Broker's Edge Realty
92300 Overseas Hwy Suite 303
Key Largo, Florida 33070

1(800) 692-3605
Contact Us

Back To TopMore Info
Terms / Privacy / Accessibility ADA