Divider
Content Divider

Tinglers Island Homes for Sale, Marathon, Florida Keys

Researching this community? View previous sales at Tinglers Island. Let one our Keys area experts help you out.

Total Listings 1
Order By:

$3,999,000
Marathon
Tinglers Island - MM: 49.50
4 Bed, 4 Baths, 3,222 SqFt Days Listed: 151
Single Family - Active - Waterfront Yes
Side of Island: Ocean - Dockage: n/a

Sprawling Sombrero Beach newly renovated retreat on an oversized lot with pool, private sandy beach and Open Water Views! Currently utilized as a successful vacation rental this home boasts loads of space and elevated amenities for a family or income-producing investment opportunity! An expansive dock allows for frequent, deep-draft boating adventures with ease, just minutes to excellent fishing and diving. Fillet your fresh catch at the convenient fillet station. Cool off after a day on the water in the in-ground pool, and enjoy a cocktail paired with stunning Sunset Views in the shade of a tiki hut from your private sandy beach! Inside, this home boasts two spacious floors with loads of room to relax and unwind. Downstairs, a generous guest bedroom and bonus room used as fourth bedroom are located just off of a sizable recreational room with access to a large covered porch and the sparkling pool beyond. Upstairs features gorgeous Open Water Views as the focal point of the open concept main living space. The newly designed kitchen features quartz counters, new cabinetry & appliances surrounded on all sides by walls of impact glass and Open Water Views, an ideal backdrop for cooking and entertaining. The well-appointed primary suite comes complete with walk-in closet, porch access, and new ensuite bathroom. An additional guest bedroom offers comfortable accommodation also with newly renovated en suite bathroom. The sprawling upstairs covered porch provides ample space for grilling and al fresco dining. Take in breathtaking views of the Open Ocean, beach, pool, and manicured yard from this breezy vantage point. Nestled on nearly half an acre, with lush tropical landscaping, this spectacular property feels tranquil and private while still just minutes to Sombrero Beach, fantastic restaurants, and grocery stores in town.

More Info
Most Recent Sales - (4) - Tinglers Island as of 2025-06-16
Sale Date Address Sale Price $/SF List Price Sq. Ft. Type Bd/Ba Days Listed
04-24-2025 250 Tingler $2,700,000 $954 $3,100,000 2,829 Single Family 3/4 73
02-14-2025 68 Tingler $1,575,000 $914 $1,650,000 1,722 Single Family 2/2 374
04-15-2024 65 Tingler $1,450,000 $1,176 $1,450,000 1,232 Single Family 2/2 118
08-01-2023 64 Tingler $1,700,000 $916 $1,749,900 1,854 Single Family 3/2 151
Thinking about selling your Tinglers Island home?

Get a free no obligation home value report and know your home's value, even if you are just curious. If you decide to sell or are considering it, our company specializes in selling homes in your community and we can provide you with the guidance on the process that will generate the most return on your investment. Inquire below for a free comparative market analysis of your property. All communication is private and no obligation.

Provide us with some quick details so we can setup a free no obligation and confidential phone call.

More Info


Enter
dsfj
The information being provided by the Florida Keys MLS is exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Data last updated on 06-16-2025.
Back To TopMore Info
Terms / Privacy / Accessibility ADA